> Lisp can only metaprogram its own syntax, you can't introduce a C-like syntax.
This is a flat-out false statement, and it reflects a deep but sadly common misunderstanding of how Lisp works and why it's cool. Even if Lisp did not have reader macros as a standard feature, you could still write a C compiler in Lisp more easily than you could write one in any other language. The whole concept of "metaprogramming a syntax" (so that you can talk about whether or not a language can "only metaprogram its own syntax") is non-sensical, a category error. Metaprogramming is simply writing programs that write programs. What makes Lisp cool is that it separates the syntax from the program. A Lisp program, unlike all other languages, is not text. A Lisp program is a data structure. Lisp happens to define a textual surface syntax (S-expressions) that allows you to easily convert text into the particular data structures that are Lisp programs (and also incidentally data structures that are not Lisp programs) but you can also produce these data structures in other ways, like, for example, writing programs that produce them. The textual surface syntax is a detail. Writing an infix parser in Lisp is an elementary exercise, and you could use that parser to parse C-like code whether or not you had reader macros. All reader macros let you do is seamlessly integrate that C-like syntax into the Lisp REPL rather than having to embed your new language in strings or read it from files.
On a different note, would you say that Lisp's syntax is better because it makes an easy compile target (i.e. it's easier to compile C into Lisp instead of x86) or because it makes writing macros/AST transformations easier? I ask because my biggest beef with Lisp has always been that I thought its S-expressions to be less readable than other languages, but if you're arguing for Lisp's value as a compile target, then that makes a lot of sense.
Not quite. Lisp's syntax is (mostly) irrelevant. Lisp's design is better because you don't have to worry about syntax to use Lisp as a compile target.
There's a huge conceptual difference between
(eval '(some code))
and (using Javascript or Python as an example) eval("Some code")
In JS/Python case you are passing a string to EVAL. In the Lisp case you are passing a data structure to EVAL. That data structure has been generated by the reader (by virtue of using QUOTE) but that is not the important part. You could as easily have written: (eval (cons (quote some) (cons (quote code) nil)))
or (eval (some-function-that-generates-code))
with the point being that some-function-that-generates-code does not return a string, it returns a data structure, so there is no syntax. The whole concept has evaporated because you're not dealing with strings any more. Syntax is for humans. When you have programs writing programs, syntax just gets in the way. But when your EVAL function takes a textual representation of a program as a string you have no choice but to muck with syntax. This is the reason that the misconception that syntax is essential is so widespread. It seems essential only because most programming languages don't distinguish between READ and EVAL.
You can. Reader macros let you put whatever syntax you want on top of Sexprs. For example:
The code for this is here: https://github.com/rongarret/ergolib