What you want. Not what you're making now. For example, I don't currently have any toxic co-workers, but in a move, I take that risk. You've got to pay me enough more to make it worth my while to move.
I've decided that my answer to "How much are you making now?" will be "That's not a relevant number. The two relevant numbers are how much it would take for me to want to take the job, and how much you think I'm worth." (I've never actually tried it, since I've been on my current job for seven years, and I came up with that more recently.)
and no, it doesn't go without saying. you need to say it. tell them your requirements. do it without them asking.
what if you wanted to buy a car, but the dealer wouldn't tell you the price? what would you do? offer them MORE than what you think the car is worth?
amateur hour advice like "never be the first one to name a price" is nonsense. just tell them what you want and see if there's a fit, or not. it's how business gets done 99% of the time.