Re:Training Computers to Find Future Criminals
by armitron on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @11:12AM
(#12122217)
It's a lot harder to hide biases in code than you assume. Even if that takes place, code can be updated and those biases can be removed, easily. If they're not removed, at least we know what they are.
Can you do the same with the human subconscious? Maybe, given lots of time and effort.
How do you evaluate success? Can you do it at scale? I don't think so.
Re:Training Computers to Find Future Criminals
by sdenton4 on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:24AM
(#12121944)
Racists have emotions, too, and often make decisions based on them. 'Feeling' that someone is suspicious is a classic cover for racial profiling.
Re:Training Computers to Find Future Criminals
by coldtea on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @02:38PM
(#12123774)
>Racists have emotions, too, and often make decisions based on them
And knives can be used both for murdering people and spreading jam on your bread.
The answer to "racist emotions" are emotions of empathy and love towards the other, and not some objective logic that one can follow to fix racism.
After all, one could always use objective logic to justify racism if one wants to -- e.g. "blacks are involved in a higher percentage of violent crimes compared to their population". That's a totally objective statement, it just skips trying to find the reasons why that might be so, and uses the numbers to justify thinking of them as violent inherently.
Explicitly as in coding them, but not necessarily as doing it consciously. After all biases are just how people see reality, so it would be natural to code based on one's biases.
Also it's less the biases (that are inevitable), and more the blind following of biases (algorithmically) that I'm concerned about.
>Going with an algorithm would minimize unconscious biases, and prevent us from reaching a conclusion based on emotion
The latter is not necessarily (or even commonly) bad, it's more of a citation needed kind of thing. I'd rather we DO reach conclusions based on emotions. Naked logic sees everything as black and white, it's emotions that make civilisation nuanced (including empathy, pity, gut instinct, abhorrence, etc).