Re:Show HN: CC0 Avatar placeholder service
by sanqui on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @09:34AM
(#12121630)
Not everybody uses a photo of a face for an avatar. :)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Show HN: CC0 Avatar placeholder service
by spdustin on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:10AM
(#12121857)
Even with the emoticon, that comment seemed designed to put down the project by suggesting its author is shortsighted and has failed to see how things really work in the really real world.
Was it your intent to condescend and hope it goes unnoticed by the addition of a few bits of punctuation? To belittle the work that went into it? Because, to be frank with you, that's how it seemed to me.
All I can say is it absolutely wasn't my intent to belittle the work that went into the project. I only felt like sharing what went through my mind when seeing that all of the avatars were faces.
There are many sites where faces are expected, like Facebook or LinkedIn. The internet is larger than that, though, and some people prefer to identify in other ways. Maybe I should've been more explicit about the conversation starter.
Re:Show HN: CC0 Avatar placeholder service
by moron4hire on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @09:42AM
(#12121672)
What does that have to do with placeholders? Lorem Ipsum doesn't accurately represent all the types of things people write.
Re:Show HN: CC0 Avatar placeholder service
by vertex-four on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @09:49AM
(#12121713)
No, but the point of Lorem Ipsum is it blends into the page reasonably, real text or not. If you were writing e.g. a template for a piece of forum software which doesn't use real names, the vast majority of people use avatars that are not pictures of faces, and if you wound up designing around face pictures (bright, certain colour tones, etc etc), your design might clash slightly with what people actually use.
Re:Show HN: CC0 Avatar placeholder service
by spdustin on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:12AM
(#12121868)
Well then you wouldn't use this project, would you? I wouldn't use a phone book for a user directory, but I also wouldn't suggest the phone company has failed by not releasing a book consisting solely of my employees' details.
Re:Show HN: CC0 Avatar placeholder service
by WorldMaker on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:17AM
(#12121894)
In which case you might use something more like https://robohash.org/ (which was just the first off top of my head).
There are a number of convert a hash to some stylized avatar tools out there already. I've seen fewer examples like Pravatar with actual headshot photos for design use.