News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by benologist on Monday March 22, 2010 @11:26PM (#1212118)
While I agree in general with what you're saying I don't think most of it applies to Google's situation.

- Google was never forced to do anything. They chose to. The cost of doing business in any location is abiding by any number of laws that businesses must evaluate to see if they're willing or profitably able to operate within.

- They didn't seem to have many moral problems for the first 4 years.

- They very publicly announced they had a problem with the situation and tried to force the Chinese governments hand with an ultimatum - change the laws or lose Google's business.

Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by scott_s on Monday March 22, 2010 @11:46PM (#1212153)
Perhaps they did have moral problems, but decided that providing some access to the internet's vast amount of information to Chinese users was better than providing none. It's the reform-from-within approach. Perhaps they hoped the situation would improve with time, and then it didn't, or there was indication it was not going to in the foreseeable future.

I don't have any more evidence for those motives than you do for the ones you presented.

Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by benologist on Monday March 22, 2010 @11:55PM (#1212168)
I really hate that argument. It's not like the internet stops existing or has no value or information if you can't use Google to find stuff. Even in China - Baidu has existed since 2000, and Google had enough confidence in what Baidu was doing to buy 2.6% of their shares a year before they decided to tackle the Chinese market themselves.

All they were ever bringing to China was the opportunity for themselves to make money. Just like any business anywhere.

Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by zaphar on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @12:48AM (#1212240)
Except for the fact that google was allowed to get away less censoring than the other search engines as well as making it obvious that filtering was going on. Google provided a service in china while making that money and improved the freedoms of Chinese citizens with the above mentioned tools.

I'm proud that google is not above turning away from money on moral grounds. And whether you buy the Press Releases or not they seem to have had plenty of moral reasons for the withdrawal.

Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by fnid2 on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @04:00AM (#1212471)
They didn't turn away from taking money on moral grounds. In fact, they censored results for 4 years until now. Why now do you think, after 4 years they are changing their stance?

Did it take them four years to come to their senses? Why now?

Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by scott_s on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @09:49AM (#1212874)
I outlined a possible reason above. I don't know if it is true, but you haven't seemed to acknowledge that it may be true.
Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by fnid2 on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @12:46PM (#1213365)
It may be true. I wonder though, if google had 75% of the market share in china search, would this be happening right now?
Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by benologist on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @03:01AM (#1212407)
"Except for the fact that google was allowed to get away less censoring than the other search engines"

No, they were and remain subject to the same laws and policies the PRC decides. That's why they're leaving.

Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by scott_s on Monday March 22, 2010 @11:59PM (#1212176)
The internet would be significantly less valuable to me if I couldn't use Google.
Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by benologist on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @12:03AM (#1212182)
Why? There's other search engines, other maps, other email providers, other blog platforms, other analytics systems, other instant messengers, other social networks, other rss readers etc.

All that would happens is you'd replace whatever you use with something else, just like every other time something online stops being available.

Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by krschultz on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @01:22AM (#1212288)
There were definitely no search engines as good as Google pre-Google.
Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by benologist on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @03:08AM (#1212414)
Sure, in 1998. This is 2010 though, there are alternatives especially in China where Google's never even had majority market share.

Even outside of China there are alternatives even if we laugh at their efforts - at this point if you hid Bing behind Google's interface people probably wouldn't even notice the difference most of the time. DuckDuckGo's made by a single guy and seems to be widely applauded.

The biggest argument against some competitors is how familiar we are with Google rather than actual inferiority.

Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by heresy on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @05:56AM (#1212574)
Have you used the internet from within China?

Baidu cannot compete internationally on the strength of their technology. The quality of their results is sub-par, and subject to gaming if you have enough money to pay them. Their market share is as big as it is because of the fact that Baidu is essentially the Chinese Pirate Bay.

Feats somewhat more difficult to reproduce when competing on a level playing field where promoting, aiding and abetting piracy is somewhat frowned upon.

Who would want to compete with the deck stacked against you like that? Sure, China's market may be big enough to mask such deficiencies, blinded as everyone is by that 1 billion+ number, but its a net loss, long term, losing access to a quality competitor.

Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by runT1ME on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @02:21AM (#1212366)
"Google was never forced to do anything."

Lol wut. You need to think about what you're saying. Go "not doing anything" they would be serving up whatever content their algorithm deems relevant.

Its 'censoring' that is doing something, and they simply chose not to do it.

Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by benologist on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @02:52AM (#1212399)
They made a deliberate and conscious decision to move into the Chinese market, with full awareness of the laws and regulations they would be bound to.
Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by fnid2 on Monday March 22, 2010 @11:34PM (#1212140)
- They didn't seem to have many moral problems for the first 4 years.

The reason Google didn't have a problem for the first 4 years, is because for the first 4 years it wasn't clear who was going to win the search engine war in China. Now it is clear, the winner is Baidu.

Google is leaving China because they have clearly lost in China and rather than take second place, they are inventing a principled stand and forcing China to kick them out.

Baidu has 3/4 of the search market in China and it's growing.[1] Rather than Google search traffic hitting zero, they're leaving in a political charade. What better excuse for losing to Baidu?

[1] http://brainstormtech.blogs.fortune.cnn.com/2009/12/28/googl...

Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by gscott on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @05:00AM (#1212517)
30% of a market the size of China doesn't seem like loosing. Companies survive off of much less, 1% of the market is often plenty enough.
Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by fnid2 on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @11:26AM (#1213121)
Except they have barely half that percentage and it's declining.
Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by gscott on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @03:40AM (#1228623)
The problem is dealing with a socialist country you never really own what you have made. They can come in anytime and take away your manufacturing plant, confiscate your physical goods, or block your website. It always happens without fail.
Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by richardw on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @04:57AM (#1212514)
Google has 1/3rd of the Chinese market, which it got after Baidu was entrenched. That is pretty much what MS and Yahoo have collectively (IIRC) in the rest of the world, but nobody says they don't factor. Google is very much aware of them, as Baidu is of Google in China.
Re:Google, don't politicalize yourself — China's official ne... by fnid2 on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @11:30AM (#1213129)
I'd like to see a source for that claim, because the source I provided above says google has 17% or so.