Re:MIT scientists find weird quantum effects over hundreds o...
by suprgeek on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @05:53PM
(#12125226)
Lets not forget that they are speaking about neutrinos - particles that are notoriously hard to detect precisely because they hardly interact with "regular" matter.
So the fact that they traveled hundreds? of miles still in superposition states just means that they did not interact with anything over those distances.
I am failing to understand how this is weird, in-fact this is exactly what the theory calls for.
Re:MIT scientists find weird quantum effects over hundreds o...
by Animats on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:01PM
(#12124399)
Now the high-frequency trading people will have to build accelerators and detectors so they can transmit in a straight line through the earth. They could knock off an entire millisecond or two between London and New York and beat everybody else.
Re:MIT scientists find weird quantum effects over hundreds o...
by Animats on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @05:05PM
(#12124899)
A $300 million cable is being laid across the Atlantic just to cut off 5ms for high-frequency trading.[1] Bandwidth will cost 50x normal on that cable.
Re:MIT scientists find weird quantum effects over hundreds o...
by jessriedel on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @06:15PM
(#12125358)
Neutrino experiments cost of order a billion dollars. The event rate for anthropogenic neutrinos sources at the MINOS detector (from the article) is a few hundred events over 1 year.
Re:MIT scientists find weird quantum effects over hundreds o...
by XaspR8d on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @03:45PM
(#12124299)
Uninformed question: isn't this somewhat what we'd expect? Neutrinos interact very weakly with matter so they're much more likely to stay in superposition? Or is this happening at a much greater scale than expected?
Re:MIT scientists find weird quantum effects over hundreds o...
by Bartweiss on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @03:53PM
(#12124339)
That's my impression also: distance travelled as an inherent property shouldn't 'break' quantum effects. It matters only because larger scale implies a larger chance of interaction, and because it relates to no-go theorems. Still, I don't think these effects have been seen over such distances, even if they were expected.
Despite the title, the scientists quoted don't sound baffled as much as excited. I think this is a case of "we found it after all!"
Re:MIT scientists find weird quantum effects over hundreds o...
by kruczek on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @05:41AM
(#12127799)
I think the complaint is for cases when there is no valuable information behind clickbaity title - then writer gets pageviews, site gets revenue, but the user only wastes his time, getting no valuable information.
Re:MIT scientists find weird quantum effects over hundreds o...
by x1798DE on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:16PM
(#12124535)
MIT's press office is master of the clickbait-overhype one-two punch, but in this case "MIT Scientists" is a justified because this is a release from the MIT press office. It's standard form for institutions, local news, etc.
Re:MIT scientists find weird quantum effects over hundreds o...
by dkraft on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:44PM
(#12124751)
The only determination I can make is that there is no proof that the same neutrino was observed. All that was observed is neutrinos in two places. Probably are neutrinos everywhere you look.
So the fact that they traveled hundreds? of miles still in superposition states just means that they did not interact with anything over those distances.
I am failing to understand how this is weird, in-fact this is exactly what the theory calls for.
Such an experiment is also very expensive.
[1] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/news/8753784/The-300m-...
https://arxiv.org/pdf/hep-ex/0607088v2.pdf
So the bandwidth for this state-of-the-art billionish-dollar detector is measured in μbps :)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spread_Networks
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/14/opinion/krugman-three-expe...
Despite the title, the scientists quoted don't sound baffled as much as excited. I think this is a case of "we found it after all!"
Why would a writer NOT create a clickbaity title?
Every writer wants his work to be read. Would you rather have the writer create a dull title that you don't click on at all?
That robs the writer off pageviews, you of valuable information, and the site of revenue. No one benefits.