Thom, you are collateral damage from a rational decision that an American with no history has something to hide. Their defaults are measurably stratospheric compared to folks with positive history. There are nondefault risks such as property damage or running a meth lab, which will cost the landlord five figures to clean if it does not raze the property. Apologies for the inconvenience.
In Denmark it's the other way around. You don't get a credit history you get marked as a bad payer. In other words you are not forced to take on debt to show that you can pay your rent instead you are checked to see if you are a bad payer.
I have lived in the US and had to build a credit history to rent a flat. I never understood why this is good for anyone but the banks.