Re:SpaceX Picks Rocket for First Relaunch
by walrus01 on Sunday July 17, 2016 @09:43PM
(#12112822)
I'd be surprised if any insurer would touch the first few re-uses of a first stage, considering how risk averse they are... For the largest commercial market segment which is geostationary telecom satellites in the 1900 to 6000 kilogram size range, they only insure well known and proven launch vehicles. I could see the first stage re-use being used for a government launch of a geostationary weather satellite or similar, or perhaps a NASA funded development project like launching a spare TDRS-type satellite, but I'd be surprised to see a commercial client like Intelsat, AsiaSat, Eutelsat, Arabsat, etc.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
You'd be surprised at what insurers are willing to insure. It just depends on what price. Just because there is no specific data about reusable rockets doesn't mean it can't be insured based on other factors.
Depending on the price of insurance, launching with a reused rocket could be more expensive than a new one. The discount that SpaceX is offering is relatively small compared to the cost of replacing a satellite, if I recall correctly.
Re:SpaceX Picks Rocket for First Relaunch
by greglindahl on Sunday July 17, 2016 @10:05PM
(#12112882)
Actually it's more the reverse: the insurance market is pretty competitive, and most GEO comsats are purchased by a small number of companies that launch a lot. That leaves a lot of room for pressure on an insurer.
I would bet there are a number of insurers willing to do so, if only to get their foot in the door for suture launches. They may require some sort of data sharing to allow them to develop actuarial models, which would then mean they could offer truly competitive insurance rates...