News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One way to make containers network: BGP by tptacek on Sunday July 17, 2016 @04:49PM (#12111750)
Especially since there isn't really a policy-routing component to this, isn't BGP pretty _extremely_ complicated for the problem Calico is trying to solve?

Stipulating that you need a routing protocol here (you don't, right? You can do proxy ARP, or some more modern equivalent of proxy ARP.), there's a whole family of routing protocols optimized for this scenario, of which OSPF is the best-known.

Re:One way to make containers network: BGP by kijiki on Sunday July 17, 2016 @05:06PM (#12111818)
One reason you sometimes "need" BGP for this is because the networking team is highly skeptical about their ToR switches accepting routes from the server team's hypervisors/containervisors. BGP route filtering on the ToRs makes them feel more secure and happy.

Opinions vary whether this is a real concern, or just a way for the networking team to maintain their relevance.

Re:One way to make containers network: BGP by X-Istence on Sunday July 17, 2016 @07:11PM (#12112360)
Calico is installing routes in the Linux kernel. Those routes are pulled out and distributed using BIRD. BIRD can do OSPF instead if you'd like.

All Calico cares about is that routes are distributed across various systems, they don't necessarily care how you do it (configure BIRD however you'd like).

BGP is surprisingly simple and easy to set up with BIRD. Setting up a route reflector with local hosts on the same L2 all peering with each other and suddenly you can route whatever IP's you want by announcing them to your peers.

Why do people think BGP is complicated?

Re:One way to make containers network: BGP by hueving on Sunday July 17, 2016 @11:53PM (#12113148)
>Why do people think BGP is complicated?

Read your own paragraph before this question. Why do I need to run another process to exchange routes and configure a mesh or a route reflector? As an admin that's just another mess of processes and communication to worry about.

Just because BGP is easy for you does not mean it's easy for most server admins and devs without heavy networking backgrounds.

Re:One way to make containers network: BGP by X-Istence on Monday July 18, 2016 @12:11PM (#12115939)
Wait what? How else should we be exchanging routes? Should we shove them into a distributed key value store and then having each of the nodes pull out the routes and installing them?

> As an admin that's just another mess of processes and communication to worry about.

Yet we fully expect admins to understand and build HA redundant clusters for databases, or how to manage and update all the machines under their control, and a variety of other tasks.

There is nothing inherently different about running a BGP speaking daemon. It's all config.

I don't have a heavy networking background at all. I'm a software engineer that's currently working as a system architect, but even I can understand something as simple as a route distribution system.

Re:One way to make containers network: BGP by tptacek on Sunday July 17, 2016 @10:16PM (#12112904)
Because BGP is complicated compared to intradomain routing protocols.
Re:One way to make containers network: BGP by X-Istence on Monday July 18, 2016 @12:12PM (#12115948)
In this case you are using BGP only for it's ability to send routes from one place to another.

This isn't complicated, it's config management. You can ignore 99% of what BGP can do in this use case.