News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ethereum Wallet and Mist Beta with Hard Fork choice by HappyFunGuy on Sunday July 17, 2016 @11:26AM (#12110448)
How decentralized is a platform that hardforks via human intervention? What happens when the 51% choose to take the money of the 49%? If your blockchain changes the rules, because someone followed the rules of the code, but following those rules led to the "wrong" people losing money. Then your blockchain is more harmful than useful.
Re:Ethereum Wallet and Mist Beta with Hard Fork choice by vertex-four on Sunday July 17, 2016 @11:35AM (#12110473)
> What happens when the 51% choose to take the money of the 49%?

What happens when the 51% desires to violate the rights of the 49% in general? (Or, more commonly in the real world, 10% desires to violate the rights of 0.5% and 85% don't care.) Direct democracy refuses to solve that issue in any way other than assuming that the minority will be successful at returning violence against the majority, or that everyone will just get along.

In practice, though, nobody's actually stealing your money here... you can still use the old chain if you want, it'll just be devalued to the point of uselessness.

Re:Ethereum Wallet and Mist Beta with Hard Fork choice by heliumcraft on Sunday July 17, 2016 @11:38AM (#12110480)
"your blockchain"?.. This is not a football team or a clan, there is no "my"/"your"...

Decentralized systems work by consensus and by choice, for the DAO the consensus of the community is to stop the theft. Some might disagree and move to their own fork.

In the scenario of the "51%" you described, the "49%" would simply move to their own forked chain if they so choose.