I don't think it's correct to say jury nullification is part of the designed system of checks and balances. It's really an unintended side effect of the jury system, since jurors have to be immune from any punishment or the system wouldn't work. The intended checks on judicial overreach are the legislative branch repealing laws and impeaching judges, and the executive branch issuing pardons.
I would call jury nullification a form of civil disobedience. That doesn't mean it's wrong, it's just not really operating inside the judicial framework. There's a reason the Supreme Court has consistently held that the defense does not have the right to inform the jury of their right to nullify.
Re:Home Free
by PantaloonFlames on Friday July 15, 2016 @08:50PM
(#12104692)
> It's really an unintended side effect of the jury system, since jurors have to be immune from any punishment or the system wouldn't work.
or in other words, an intended side-effect.
Re:Home Free
by CompelTechnic on Friday July 15, 2016 @02:08PM
(#12102790)
I think I remember reading somewhere that if you demonstrate knowledge about jury nullification during the screening process when you are called for jury duty, you will be screened out as a juror. Which is frickin' ridiculous!
Re:Home Free
by crispyambulance on Friday July 15, 2016 @03:51PM
(#12103390)
You can be screened out for literally ANYTHING during voire dire. It really is up to the lawyers and their prejudices and based entirely on your superficial appearance.
But if you just don't want to serve, don't waste everyone's time-- just say you can't be objective, or better, give a hardship excuse before the court date.
The Law You Won't Be Told
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqH_Y1TupoQ
A) They can't be punished for their verdict B) They can, and should, consider the rule of law, and not just the veracity of the evidence as is often directed by the judge C) They have the authority to say "okay, the evidence shows the defendant is guilty, but we don't think the law is a just one, so we're going to acquit."
Sometimes, that power is used for good (not convicting those who helped runaway slaves, for example, or not convicting minor drug offenses, keeping our disgustingly overcrowded county jails from adding to their rolls) and sometimes not (the officers acquitted despite video evidence of their beating Rodney King).
It is, however, an exemplar of the checks-and-balances meant to constrain a government that may otherwise overstep its boundaries to violate a citizen's rights. While the rights afforded to a jury are in danger of changing, they haven't changed yet, and potential jurors everywhere in the US should read up more on their rights and responsibilities as a juror.