News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senator Elizabeth Warren joins call for Airbnb probe by SilasX on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @04:37PM (#12089486)
Depends on what counts as "protecting the lodging industry". There are deliberate, long-instated taxes and regulations on it, usually as a means to capture, for the government, some of the surplus value generated by tourism. It's especially popular because of the (relatively correct) belief that the taxes are borne by non-residents. [2]

It's eminently understandable why governments would want all providers of lodging to play by the same rules[1] so that people can't circumvent such "tourism taxes".

There are likewise considerations of zoning/deed restrictions/HOAs/condo boards to think about. You generally do not have the (legal, and usually moral) right to run arbitrary businesses in "your" unit. There are things that people expect out of their home unit's community, and which they all deliberately accepted as a condition, like "not having a major stream of randos going in and out".

Communities also generally have an interest in regulating the percentage and location of buildings for permanent residents vs visitors. Generally speaking, permanents take better care of the surroundings, albeit at a "cost" of paying less for the space per unit time, and there's a quick ramp-up in social ills and livability problems when you let the ratios go out whack, or concentrate the visitors in areas not prepared for them.

To the extent that Airbnb is breaking that whole model, it's reasononable to either throttle it or research ways that they can share in the burden they're bringing on without losing the upside.

[1] modulo scale, of course -- it's fair to expect some exemption for sporadic, one-off arrangements, and it's fair for Airbnb to facilitate that

[2] I say "relatively" because the economic incidence will never be fully on visitors, but will partially be shared by the lodging industry, in having to charge less to remain competitive with other destinations.

There are no comments on this comment yet.