> So, think before jumping on the "they're all ignorant Luddites" bandwagon...
The immediate reaction being to protect entrenched interests has nothing to do with the "ignorant Luddites" as far as I'm concerned. I'm thinking more, when was the last time a Federal regulator probed something in order to actually benefit the little guy?
AirBNB by its nature creates very local issues. I think the appropriate place to look and regulate is at the local level. Towns and residents can take it upon themselves to restrict unwanted activities or they can choose not to, based on the impacts to their communities. Going bigger than that with anything more than light regulation would promote a one size fits all approach, which wouldn't work considering towns and cities are very different from one another.
Is it a good idea to expect that a global service be forced to deal with a crazy-quilt patchwork of likely conflicting local regs? Obviously the service wants no reg, but if they're smart, they should want single fed regs, vs potentially unlimited local versions.
And of course, are there federal concerns vs local concerns, e.g., taxation, undeclared income, effects on the capital gain on the buildings (someone renting out a house regularly shouldn't get the same cap gains exception as on a building used fully as a primary residence), etc., which make it pretty reasonable to look at it from that level.
Federal taxation is a wholly separate issue. It arises out of the commercial gains, not the use of the land. Put another way, we don't intermingle Federal tax and permissible activities, the tax code doesn't tell you that you can't use your boat a certain way to generate income. It just speaks to what taxes you pay on the income (sometimes the income generated in that manner).
Sure, there may be some of that.
However, we in the tech community need to recognize that doing something at scale creates a fundamental difference of kind, not merely of quantity. Of course, to a large degree, that is the point of much modern tech, to take something that was simply local word-of-mouth stuff ("oh, my friend's got an apartment empty next month, perhaps you two can work out house-sitting for your visit" or "oh, she needs a ride to town too") and turning it into an instant service, globally scaled. This is what creates $billions of value with minimal infrastructure.
However, it is nonsense to say that there are no negative externalities, or that they are all trivial and ignore-able, or merely old incumbents protecting their ill-gotten economic territory.
Consider another potential technology that could be easily scaled -- speeding tickets. Instead of relying on the local cop to manually measure your speed, chase you down, write a ticket and testify in court, they could simply get the data off your smartphone and ticket you ever time you sent over-speed. They could just argue that "this is just the same law as we've always had". But the result would be that instead of maybe one ticket every X+ years, most of us would get multiple tickets every time we drove outside of a traffic jam. It would fundamentally change everything about driving and the related economy.
Similarly, it's one thing when a few people casually rent out a room for a few days a year, or get a house-sitter when they go on vacation. But, it is altogether different when the information exchange infrastructure becomes sufficiently reliable and networked that it makes sense for people to run lodging as a business, even buying houses just for that purpose.
This substantially distorts the real estate market, and dumps a lot of externalities on neighbors. It is one thing to buy a house or condo on the assumption that the neighbors are all residents with investment in the neighborhood/building -- quite another to expect that all of the people around you are completely transient. And, of course, even worse when the situation changes after you've moved in.
So, please think a bit before jumping on the "they're all ignorant Luddites" bandwagon...
(edit - grammar/clarity)