If you're not affecting your neighbors, it's nobody's business what you do on your property, including letting other people live there. If you want to regulate, add some additional regulations about behavior that affects neighboring properties but isn't currently covered.
You say that, but there are currently many, many cities trying to get Airbnb to deal with their illegal apartments, and yet Airbnb is stalling on that (presumably because if you shut down their illegal apartments, their valuation would implode).
To your point, "affecting your neighbors" is a pretty tough thing to track down. Even if things seem to be going well, there's a difference between having stable neighbors who take care of the neighborhood and an unknown rolling of the dice every few days. If you have kids, it's an even bigger risk. It's very difficult to accurately judge just how much of an impact it has, which is why cities have set up zoning regulations.
Why should AirBnB want to help jurisdictions that are trying to shut it down completely under the guise of "illegal apartments/hotels"? It's an entirely different matter to help keep the residents of AirBnB rentals behaving well and not disturbing their neighbors, which seems completely reasonable.
> there's a difference between having stable neighbors who take care of the neighborhood
There's no guarantee that "stable" neighbors care either, and "take care of the neighborhood" would need to be a lot more precise to be either enforceable or appropriate. There's a reason we specifically looked for a house without a "neighborhood association", and several people I know who currently have such associations would like to get out from under them. Banning AirBnB does sound consistent with neighborhood-association-style politics, though.
Saying you want to regulate tenancy duration rather than behavior seems a lot like choosing to reject browsers based on User-Agent rather than doing feature detection. All tenants should behave well regardless of tenancy duration; any well-behaved neighbor should be equivalently fine regardless of tenancy duration.
> If you have kids, it's an even bigger risk.
"Think of the children!" does not increase the weight of your argument. You're talking very nebulously about risk. The previous comments were specifically complaining about things like noise and late-night parties.
Seems like there's a better solution available here.
I'm saying that existing residential zoning laws are only effective when you can apply them to actual residents.
They fall flat if you have to chase people down (what, across state lines?) or if the fines aren't high enough to eat into an Airbnb revenue stream.
Which, is one reason why we have zoning laws in the first place - because the penalties and proxies in a commercial zone are different than they are in a residential one.
> but they're going to solve it with different, shittier laws that make less sense
Not sure how residents voting to ban short-term residential rentals in their community is shitty or senseless.
The zoning laws seem to be used only because cities are not even trying to properly police the already in place nuisance laws.
It depends on the laws. Some municipalities could have laws that are able to handle short-term rentals while others could not.
In a jurisdiction where the existing law doesn't address a problem caused by short-term rentals, a new law would not be arbitrary - in fact, it would be the exact opposite.
> The zoning laws seem to be used only because cities are not even trying to properly police the already in place nuisance laws.
If zoning laws are easier to enforce than nuisance laws, this could be an appropriate response.