Re:Obamacare’s sinking safety net
by antisthenes on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @04:06PM
(#12089229)
Companies that find they are losing money in individual states should be forced to bite the bullet.
I'm still amazed that these companies are allowed to make a profit in the first place. Yes, there will be bad states, but you shouldn't be allowed to just stop offering coverage until you're actually losing money as a company overall.
The ACA provided over $2 billion in startup funds for about three dozen non-profit health care co-ops (new insurance companies) who were meant to provide competition, increased choice and lower prices for consumers. Almost all of these co-ops are now bankrupt thanks to a medley of fraud and incompetence. As noted elsewhere in the thread, Land of Lincoln in IL just publicly announced their dissolution today. What happened? Well, it turns out running an insurance company is hard, and in return for doing that hard job, the executives, even of these non-profits, want to be paid a lot of money. In many cases the Government allocated startup funds to politically-connected individuals who sucked it out of the system and into their own pockets. So no, the grass isn't always greener. You can't just slap a ''non-profit'' label on something and expect problems to be fixed. And to the extent you pay executives less money, they will work less, and in the absence of that leadership, systemic future risks start to accumulate. The selfish profit motive is still one of the core values that our society depends upon in order to function the way we expect it to. Gordon Gekko put it one way: ''Greed is Good!''. Milton Friedman another: ''Nirvana is not for this world.'' Not yet, at least.
Congress also pulled funding for the risk corridors system that was supposed to keep insurers who were unlucky in the exchanges (i.e. getting sicker, more expensive customers) afloat. The co-ops suffered particularly badly from that.
Re:Obamacare’s sinking safety net
by belovedeagle on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @04:58PM
(#12089608)
> denying helping people with pre-existing conditions
This is literally the definition of insurance: insurance is a pool of risk, entered into by a large number of people who have not incurred a certain rare circumstance, against the possibility of them encountering that circumstance. This isn't insurance companies being greedy! What if all insurance worked this way?
It's true, but what this really demonstrates is that insurance is not the best model for delivering healthcare. Unfortunately it's our starting point in the US and a more fundamental change is not politically tenable now (or in the foreseeable future), so we have to take what incremental improvements we can get.
Health insurance is different from most other forms of insurance, though - auto insurance, for example, doesn't pay for oil changes to mitigate the risk of expense of future liability claims.
Re:Obamacare’s sinking safety net
by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @05:52PM
(#12089959)
At least in my country it is very common for auto insurance companies to pay to have windscreen chips repaired, as it's cheaper than waiting for the whole window to fail (possibly causing am accident in the process).
True, but that's still not preventative any more than a tooth filling is (Sorry, switched industries, but I think it still makes sense).
automobile risk avoidance is a lot less complex than health risk avoidance - a lot more people change their own oil than draw their own blood. Also, oil changes would only mitigate the risk of early engine failure which wouldn't be covered by typical policies.
Okay, that was a bad example. I've never carried comprehensive/collision insurance, so I mistakenly thought there was coverage for mechanical failures. As you stated, this is not common.
Eh, I don't see my health insurance as "insurance". I see the company as my health care "agent". When I get sick, I'm not in any position to negotiate or compare prices between providers, so I'm going to rely on the negotiating that my insurance company has already done on my behalf. And what better way to ensure that my agent is really trying their best to get the best price for me? Make them pay the cost and I'll pay a set monthly fee for everything.
Re:Obamacare’s sinking safety net
by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @05:59PM
(#12089997)
This would be like car insurance covering you for damage incurred in the first 5 seconds of a crash, or the first inch of a flood, and then declaring everything that happens afterwards as a "pre-existing condition".
Re:Obamacare’s sinking safety net
by thefastlane on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @05:34PM
(#12089838)
i think the dictionary definition of 'insurance' is beside the point. this is really about sustainable ways ('sustainable' comes with many facets to be considered, to be sure) to ensure health care is provided to society and how we shape/modify our social contract to attain that.
The honest reality is that these costs did exist before, it's just they were paid by the sick in our society by dying, while the health insurance companies skimmed off the cream from the healthy. No free lunch, right? So this cost existed, only by law, it was pushed onto the healthcare companies after the ACA
It is quite bad though, as the article details, costs have reached 100% of premiums at least in NC it looks like. That is unsustainable, and since the ACA went ahead with requiring healthcare companies to help pull this off, without something like a public option to cover say the super sick, this isn't good news.
All around, this is a bad. But it's not like ACA made it worse, it just made the costs appear somewhere else, and as the article states, absent of any new policy, that cost will shift back to the sick who will have to die again.