I think its pretty derogatory and unprofessional. See how far Brain Guy goes in an organization with one psychologist. I would imagine a "rebuke" and a remembrance of the word "Doctor" would occur.
"How I Met Your Mother" was a comedy, and that what a [JOB] Guy title makes the person.
Or that character in 'How I met your mother' who had a suit guy, a Yankees ticket guy, a flower guy and – if new needs arise – a guy guy.