News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Model S Autopilot Reliability – Why Americans Shoul... by ModernMech on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @01:10PM (#12087840)
If the "future winning" means beta testing driverless car technology on unsuspecting victims, then that's not a future I want to live in, sorry.

Look, I'm a robotics engineer, so my job security and career prospects directly depend on technologies like autonomous cars becoming mainstream.

That said, the way Tesla is rolling out this technology is just irresponsible. An excellent post from yesterday [1] succinctly outlined the deficiencies of the system, which are now obvious to people outside of Tesla. Given this list, if I were in charge there, this technology would NOT see the light of day until these defects were properly fixed.

Beyond the technical problems, there is also a social issue that Tesla is exacerbating. For the last few years now, the general public has been hearing from a variety of popular media sources that autonomous cars are "right around the corner". People have been told that these cars will use their superior computer minds to virtually eliminate traffic accidents.

Now you have Tesla producing a car with a feature that sounds a lot like "driverless car" to normal people; right or wrong, it seems like people are treating it with the expectation that it's one of these magical life-saving driverless cars they've been hearing about.

To Tesla's credit, the feature does work well given the correct conditions. The common user probably couldn't tell you the difference between "autopilot" and an actual autonomous car. Yet, the user is not properly aware of the limits of the system, and Tesla itself doesn't do much to educate users about those limits. Further, Tesla doesn't seem to do anything to keep users safe when they get close to those edges.

What you have here is insufficient and untested technology being used in a production environment by users who have the wrong expectations about what the technology is. The result, as we have seen, ends in death.

And no, these failures are not inevitable conclusions of statistics. These failures are due to concrete, identifiable engineering and messaging issues that can and should have been corrected before the product was ever introduced to production cars.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12084011

Re:Tesla Model S Autopilot Reliability – Why Americans Shoul... by chronolitus on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @03:56PM (#12089148)
I agree with that sentiment, however

> unsuspecting victims

Is a bit much in my opinion. They are operating heavy machinery, and decide not to follow the clearly stated operational guidelines. People are not children, driving a car is a responsibility.

Note: I'm not saying that such accidents aren't tragic, or that the drivers 'deserve it' in any way. Simply pointing out that no one forced anyone to take their hands off the wheel, or subject themselves to driverless testing.

Re:Tesla Model S Autopilot Reliability – Why Americans Shoul... by ModernMech on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @04:29PM (#12089423)
Eh, I would still call them unsuspecting, but in another sense. Yes, they are the ones who bought the car and yes, they are the ones who enabled the autopilot feature, and yes, they are the ones who used it in a scenario when it wasn't appropriate.

But they are unsuspecting in that they spent $60k on a car, $2500 to install the autopilot feature, and another $3000 to just enable the autopilot feature. And what they get from that, is something that can keep a lane, but with a laundry list of caveats: It doesn't work if the road is too curvy, or if the lane markers are too faded, or in the snow or rain or dust, or if it's too sunny out, or if the obstacle is too high (but low enough that it will still decapitate you), or ... or ... or .......

So I would say, that Tesla is still testing this feature, and customers really aren't aware that they're spending ~$5500 for something they don't realize (and are not told) is deficient on multiple fronts.

Re:Tesla Model S Autopilot Reliability – Why Americans Shoul... by studentrob on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @01:20PM (#12087922)
Amen!