News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to use Elm at work by david-given on Monday July 11, 2016 @03:25PM (#12073622)
I really like the look of Elm --- to me it seems to hit the sweet spot of being enough like Haskell to be awesome while also being understandable by humans. It also fixes some of the rougher edges of the Haskell syntax; I vastly prefer Elm's record syntax to Haskell's, for example, which apart from being much cleaner and obvious also avoids some of the more common Haskell namespace traps.

The one piece I'm really looking for is server-side Elm, though. I've love the ability to write both my client and my server in Elm. I know there are some projects to allow Elm via node.js but they're still quite rough.

(Is anyone looking into transpiling Elm to Standard ML, so that it can be compiled to fast native code with MLton? Because that'd be, like, really cool.)

Re:How to use Elm at work by corysama on Monday July 11, 2016 @04:21PM (#12074148)
> while also being understandable by humans.

A famously good aspect of Elm is it's error messages. Very learner-friendly.

https://twitter.com/id_aa_carmack/status/735197548034412546

http://elm-lang.org/blog/compilers-as-assistants

http://elm-lang.org/blog/compiler-errors-for-humans

Re:How to use Elm at work by mdadm on Monday July 11, 2016 @09:50PM (#12076203)
That's freakin' awesome. Now I wish gcc or clang would have something similar :(
Re:How to use Elm at work by tunaoftheland on Monday July 11, 2016 @03:39PM (#12073732)
Agreed! While I do tell myself "right lang for the right job", I've come to the conclusion that I am lazy. :) So if Elm can run on Erlang/OTP like Elixir, that would be an interesting option for the webdev space. I don't even know if something like that is feasible, but I wonder someone's thought of such a thing?
Re:How to use Elm at work by david-given on Monday July 11, 2016 @04:04PM (#12073991)
I hadn't thought of BEAM. Apparently it's on the roadmap.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11916096

Re:How to use Elm at work by wyager on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @12:26AM (#12076723)
>while also being understandable by humans.

I don't understand how one can understand Elm and not understand Haskell, unless the expectation that Haskell is difficult makes people's brains shut down without even trying.

Most of the ML-esque concepts that make Haskell "hard" to read if you come from a C/Python/Java/etc. background (ADTs and pattern matching, application by adjacency, etc.) are present in Elm as well.

> I vastly prefer Elm's record syntax to Haskell's,

Are you familiar with Lenses? Classy lenses in Haskell provide a slightly less sexy but more powerful system of structural typing.

Re:How to use Elm at work by galfarragem on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @07:14AM (#12078110)
Elm looks like a simplified and specially a rebranded Haskell, a "functional language for humans". This could work wonders as marketing strategy but there is still a remaining pain point blocking Elm aspiration to become mainstream: community management. There is plenty of room to improve there.
Re:How to use Elm at work by nilkn on Monday July 11, 2016 @03:42PM (#12073763)
Why not just use Haskell for the backend? It's really not much harder than Elm, and it's considerably more flexible and general. Of course, it's lazy, not strict, and you're totally right that records in Haskell suck. But my understanding is that strictness for Elm was chosen mainly to overcome issues with FRP, which it's now abandoned. So I'm not sure if that difference matters anymore.
Re:How to use Elm at work by david-given on Monday July 11, 2016 @04:01PM (#12073967)
There's several reasons, one of the simplest (but not the most trivial) being that I can't share code between the client and the server. For example, data validation. I did a tonne of programming on GWT back in the day, and this was something it actually did well.

Most of the other reasons boil down to Haskell not being Elm --- they work in different ways and solve problems differently. There's always going to be impedance mismatch between the two. (Do I solve this problem with monads or with state-mutation functions?) This is going to use up valuable problem-solving bandwidth which I'd rather spend making the project more awesome.

Re:How to use Elm at work by platz on Monday July 11, 2016 @04:55PM (#12074520)
> Can't share code between client and server

The question was about using haskell on the back end. Also, previous attempts at sharing client and server code in other langs are sophmoric at best. In reality, there will always be a boundary that requires differences in front end and back end code.

> Haskell is not Elm

Doesn't answer the question, circular reasoning at best.

Re:How to use Elm at work by bbcbasic on Monday July 11, 2016 @09:39PM (#12076162)
> Haskell is not Elm

A service isn't a client though. They work in different ways and solve problems differently

Re:How to use Elm at work by phamilton on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @12:43AM (#12076784)
They also, sometimes, solve the same problem. (Cited example: data validation)

There's value in sharing code between client and server. It may not outway the costs, but there's definitely value in doing so.

Re:How to use Elm at work by bbcbasic on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @05:35AM (#12077781)
Yes true. There is the option of ghcjs on the front end, so you can do both in Haskell. And ghcjs is very close to cbc. I think it even emulates the threading model.
Re:How to use Elm at work by moosingin3space on Monday July 11, 2016 @07:16PM (#12075541)
Elm seems to have a much stronger developer UX story than Haskell (just look at how much better its error messages are than ghc's), and the ability to share data models across the frontend-backend border would be awesome -- an end-to-end typechecked stack with easy sharing.

With Elm on the server too, you could easily implement server rendering to initialize the page for fast load times.

Re:How to use Elm at work by zimbatm on Monday July 11, 2016 @04:57PM (#12074534)
With Elm you don't have to import 80 things and active 10 language extension to get anything done. :p
Re:How to use Elm at work by wyager on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @12:21AM (#12076705)
Everything that Elm can do (and more) except structural typing is standard out-of-the-box Haskell.

Most Haskell language extensions just save you some typing or give you some extra verification; they're almost never actually necessary.

Re:How to use Elm at work by bbcbasic on Monday July 11, 2016 @09:41PM (#12076165)
But in Haskell you can get anything done :-)
Re:How to use Elm at work by tmptmp on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @12:03AM (#12076658)
>>But in Haskell you can get anything done :-)

Yeah, only if you are willing to spend anything (e.g. insanely large amounts of time) on it :(

Please correct me if I am wrong, but for any large project, Haskell actually adds more woes (e.g. laziness induced problems, no good debugging support) than the ones it addresses.

The Standard Chartered people had to invent a new language (mu) [1] which doesn't have laziness and the horrors associated with it.

BTW, you can get anything done even in (any Turing complete) assembly language too!

[1] http://anil.recoil.org/papers/2011-cufp-scribe-preprint.pdf

Edit: added the Standard Chartered example

Re:How to use Elm at work by caconym_ on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @02:14PM (#12081205)
> Please correct me if I am wrong, but for any large project, Haskell actually adds more woes (e.g. laziness induced problems, no good debugging support) than the ones it addresses.

If you want to make a blanket assertion like that, then the onus is on you to provide some evidence of it. The fact that a strict dialect of Haskell exists somewhere in the world and is being used for application X is interesting, but it does not support your claim about Haskell's viability as a general-purpose language.

Re:How to use Elm at work by wyager on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @12:32AM (#12076748)
>laziness induced problems

This is like saying that Java has "strictness induced problems". It's true, but probably disingenuous. Obviously large, well-funded strict object-oriented projects have memory leak problems as well (all browsers).

> no good debugging support

One generally doesn't require as much debugging support for Haskell, but it's actually quite nice if you follow a debugging process amenable to pure functional languages. People coming from a Java background want e.g. a breakpoint debugger, which doesn't really make any sense at all in a pure functional language; a vastly superior approach is to do e.g. quickcheck-style checking or input/output debugging on pure functions. If your code is impure, you can essentially debug like normal.

Bugs in Haskell also aren't the same as most of the bugs in other languages; you never get null pointers, for example. Every bug in Haskell is either a logic bug (which can often be debugged purely, and can be minimized by the careful application of types) or an atotality bug (which can be completely avoided by totality/completeness checking, and dynamic debugging of such bugs is getting much better with the new implicit callstack feature added to recent versions of GHC).

Re:How to use Elm at work by phamilton on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @12:50AM (#12076810)
> you never get null pointers

To me, head [] is basically a null pointer.

Re:How to use Elm at work by dllthomas on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @04:35PM (#12089467)
To my mind, it differs importantly in that `head []` is something you basically can't inspect, and so you don't wind up passing it as something meaningful expecting the other side to check for it.

While I think this is an important difference, `head` is still harmful.

Re:How to use Elm at work by bbcbasic on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @05:38AM (#12077787)
You don't need to do head [] but nulls are unavoidable in Java.
Re:How to use Elm at work by tmptmp on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @08:17AM (#12078396)
How can I be sure that some lazy code (may be from some library) may not encounter "head []" at all?

Of course, I can avoid that by avoiding all such libraries.

Another painful thing is the exception handling is also not as clean and clear as, say Java/Python exception handling, AFAIK.

Please correct me if I am wrong here, and I will be a happy camper. In fact, I love Haskell as it has taught me how to think clearly. But I am scary to use it in production, sorry for that.

Re:How to use Elm at work by wyager on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @09:58AM (#12078952)
It's actually quite easy. Enable the completeness checker. It won't let you use head, because it's incomplete. In other words, it will say "stop using head".

What this entails practically is something like a) using safe head, which has type [a] -> Maybe a, or b) using the non-empty list type, or c) using streams, which don't have an empty constructor. There are lots of things you can do, but the general approach is "use pattern matching to cover all cases". The compiler can tell you if you've done this or not, and it you do your program will never crash.

>Another painful thing is the exception handling is also not as clean and clear as, say Java/Python exception handling, AFAIK.

Monadic exception handling is 100x easier than in Java or Python. Java copied Haskell/ML's use of Maybe/Optional for avoiding null pointers in Java 8, but they haven't yet figured out Haskell's use of Either and friends for exception handling.

Handling true exceptions in Haskell outside of IO code is worse than in Java, which is probably what you're thinking of, but most code bases completely avoid it. It's not hard at all. Handling true exceptions in IO is often nicer than Java, because Haskell has well-thought-out primitives like bracket.

Re:How to use Elm at work by tome on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @04:14PM (#12081986)
> Enable the completeness checker.

What's this "completeness checker"?

Re:How to use Elm at work by wyager on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @07:18PM (#12082892)
The -fwarn-incomplete-patterns ghc option.
Re:How to use Elm at work by dllthomas on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @04:30PM (#12089427)
That does not warn about using `head`. It wouldn't even warn about an attempt to define `head`, so long as you do so with a call to `undefined` or `error` (which is effectively what's done in the base libraries).
Re:How to use Elm at work by wyager on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @09:25PM (#12091098)
>That does not warn about using `head`.

You're right, I didn't realize that. Thankfully, `head` is one of the few common functions that's incomplete, and it's usually pretty obvious what they are.

> It wouldn't even warn about an attempt to define `head`, so long as you do so with a call to `undefined` or `error`

1. It's syntactically quite simple to avoid these two.

2. If you're using these, you're obviously aware your program can fail.

3. fdefer-typed-holes was introduced as a better alternative to undefined that warns you when used.

Re:How to use Elm at work by dllthomas on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:14PM (#12091260)
It's syntactically quite simple to avoid those two in your own code. You're not necessarily aware that a library you're using is using these.

That said, the community is pretty good at nudging people toward total functions, particularly in commonly used libraries (Prelude notwithstanding). And as you say, it helps that it is generally obvious when non-totality is newly introduced - infinite loops being the biggest exception, but that's unavoidable anywhere you don't have an actual totality checker.

Re:How to use Elm at work by tome on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @02:30PM (#12081319)
> The Standard Chartered people had to invent a new language (mu) [1] which doesn't have laziness and the horrors associated with it.

This is a terrible myth that needs to die. Mu is strict because it was designed to target a pre-existing strict runtime. Nothing at all to do with any perceived downsides of laziness, including space leaks.

Re:How to use Elm at work by bbcbasic on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @12:05AM (#12076667)
Was just jokingly comparing Haskell which is general purpose to elm which is for the web only.
Re:How to use Elm at work by mahyarm on Monday July 11, 2016 @05:31PM (#12074861)
Haskell has compile time problems when used in real project (tm) codebase scales and is hard to predict memory or cpu usage due to it's lazy nature sometimes.

I have no idea if elm is any better in that case, but both things make me scared to use it in production systems.

Re:How to use Elm at work by ruslan_talpa on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @03:48AM (#12077407)
This is a way to introduce space leak detection in your tests http://neilmitchell.blogspot.ro/2015/09/detecting-space-leak... so that you can sleep well and not be afraid of using Haskell in big projects :)
Re:How to use Elm at work by bjz_ on Monday July 11, 2016 @05:51PM (#12075014)
> But my understanding is that strictness for Elm was chosen mainly to overcome issues with FRP, which it's now abandoned

Laziness also requires you to ship a runtime, which is annoying on the web. Plus it's hard to debug performance problems, and you need more language complexity to allow you to opt-out of it. There are ways to opt-in to laziness in Elm via libraries, which seems to be becoming accepted as the right way to do things these days.

Re:How to use Elm at work by methehack on Monday July 11, 2016 @07:06PM (#12075492)
I wouldn't say it's understandable by all humans yet. I've had this experience where just when I think I'm grokking it, I hit a line of code that makes me cross-eyed and I can't find any traction at all and it's basically impossible to look up help. This is a combination of the maturity level of the project and also the documentation, but I get a distinctly not-quite-there-yet feeling with it (to be fair it is < 1.0). While elm has come a long way and has some great ideas, but I'm not 100% comfortable using it for something real yet.

I'm also not convinced by the cross-component communication / tree of components story yet. That still feels awkward to me. Not to turn this religious or anything, but tbh the static typing which feels like such a strength within a component, feels like it's in the way between components and results in some boilerplate, verbosity, and overly tight coupling. Really not trying to troll here -- I want to love it. YMMV.

Re:How to use Elm at work by oblique63 on Monday July 11, 2016 @09:50PM (#12076202)
> [static typing] feels like it's in the way between components and results in some boilerplate, verbosity, and overly tight coupling

Just curious, is this with regards to Elm / ML-style static typing specifically, or were you talking about it in combination with languages like C#/Java/etc?

I'm an elm noob, but I've been using F# for a good while, and its ML style of static typing is almost like the exact opposite experience of working with things like Java. Significantly less code, less boilerplate, and more expressive[0][1]. For example, one of the coolest features of F# that really showcase this, are type providers:

https://channel9.msdn.com/Blogs/Seth-Juarez/Type-Providers-i...

With them, you can leverage F#'s type system to automatically infer the structure and type of any external data source. Which means practically zero boilerplate or "ORMs" needed for things like reading-from/writing-to databases, making web api calls, parsing json/xml, or even interfacing with packages from entirely different languages like R [2].

So static typing can definitely have a lot of cool/practical benefits besides just catching bugs that make life easier, while still maintaining the flexible/lightweight feel of languages like python. However languages like C++ and Java have definitely seemed to have given it a bad name for a while, and haskell's whole tie-in with abstract math hasn't historically made it very accessible for us average programmers to notice all the tricks it has up its sleeve.

Elm is still young and I'm a total novice to it, but after working in F#, I'm definitely sold on it and like where it's going.

[0] https://fsharpforfunandprofit.com/series/why-use-fsharp.html

[1] https://skillsmatter.com/skillscasts/4971-domain-driven-desi...

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_BOST3W88-Y

Re:How to use Elm at work by phamilton on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @12:38AM (#12076766)
So here's the Elm high level on the tree of components:

An Elm component is typocally a Model type and a Msg type. When side effects occur, the component receives a call to update with the model and the message. It returns a new model and a new side effect to cause (could be none). The model is then rendered into a view.

If you have a user profile component then maybe you have a user info component and a settings component. And maybe the settings component has a notifications component and a privacy component.

The Model for that is pretty straightforward. It's just a tree of data.

The Msg for that is what is being complained about. Any side effects caused by a child component will call the update function of the parent. It then has to route that to the child component.

The result is that you have:

type Msg = ProfileMsg Profile.Msg | SettingsMsg Settings.Msg

type Profile.Msg = ...

type Settings.Msg = NotificationsMsg Notifications.Msg | PrivacyMsg Privacy.Msg

type Notifications.Msg = ...

type Privacy.Msg = ...

So now your top level msg could be a SettingsMsg (Settings.PrivacyMsg (Privacy.SetDefault Privacy.Self))

And in order to process it in update you have to unwrap the outer type (like SettingsMsg) and then call update on the child component with the data from the msg. You repeat until a component can handle it. The the component returns a new model and possible new side effect. You wrap up that side effect in something like SettingsMsg and return it along with your new model.

It's a lot of boilerplate. As far as creating coupling, what if you want to use the notification component elsewhere in the app. Now something other than Settings needs to wrap it so you get Settings.NotificationMsg and Toolbar.NotificationMsg.

It just gets clumsy.

Re:How to use Elm at work by methehack on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @04:42PM (#12089525)
Thank you for taking the time to clarify and explain. That's exactly what I was talking about.

Worth noting -- it might be that there's just a missing construct/approach itty bitty piece of language support here that would make this problem a lot smoother.

I'm actually surprised I've not heard of anyone else express something other than complete satisfaction about it as it doesn't take much messing around to whack into it.

Re:How to use Elm at work by phamilton on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @08:23PM (#12090849)
It felt less verbose on 0.16 with the Mailbox forwarding.
Re:How to use Elm at work by wyager on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @12:38AM (#12076761)
> boilerplate, verbosity, and overly tight coupling

Can you give an example? Can't think of anything off the top of my head that fits this description.