Maybe eventually the world will agree with you. We already eat the slowdown that comes with bounds-checked arrays. And indeed, compilers are getting better at removing that bit of overhead, compared to, say, the 1970s.
That said, it's been surprisingly ergonomic. If it had a compiler and could generate binaries, and if it had parity in libraries with C, I think I would strongly prefer using it to C. The massively increased safety is worth giving up a lot of expressivity for, IMO. No comparison with HLL languages for prototyping, of course. Eventually I hope to get the usual HLLs reimplemented atop it. One subtle point is that since it's refcounted at the Assembly level, any language built atop it requires minimal GC support.
The fact that it's Assembly has caused some confusion with others, so I want to point out that:
a) you can add any number of numbers in a single instruction; that gets handled behind the scenes. Many instructions are variadic where it makes sense.
b) you don't need push/pop/call to call a function, function calls look just like primitive operations.
c) Mu knows about types, so it knows how to allocate them, how to print them, and (eventually) how to serialize/unserialize them. These things can be overridden, but they work out of the box for any new types you create.
d) Mu supports generic types. Here's a generic linked-list, for example: http://akkartik.github.io/mu/html/064list.mu.html. Types starting with underscores are type parameters.
e) You get structured programming by default using the break and loop instructions which translate to jumps just after the enclosing '}' and '{' label, respectively. Factorial in Mu looks surprisingly clean: http://akkartik.github.io/mu/html/factorial.mu.html
What's common to these features is that I could imagine implementing them in a compiler using just machine language and Mu. What I'm trying to avoid is having to write a complex optimizer. These features (I think) don't massively increase the impedance mismatch between Mu and machine code; they can be implemented with basically glorified search-and-replace.
The Mu editor is built in Mu, yes. That's just because I don't have a HLL yet. It's not to say that I think everyone should build apps only in the Assembly layer. It's a little like the early days of C and Unix: until the language got stable people built the original versions of compiler and OS in Assembly. But they were eventually able to move to C.
a) next-ingredient is still around, and I still teach it first before graduating students to headers.
b) Headers get translated to next-ingredient calls behind the scenes, but without the need to type-check ingredients at runtime.
c) You might still choose to use next-ingredient if you want to implement optional arguments, or variadic functions. A weird one is interpolate (in http://akkartik.github.io/mu/html/061text.mu.html), which scans through its arguments twice, first to compute the size of the array to allocate to hold them, and then a second time to copy them over. Since calls to next-ingredient can get arbitrarily complex, Mu doesn't bother type-checking them. It just moves the type-checking for explicit calls to next-ingredient to run-time.
I'll update that post. Thanks again.
(1) It's a good question. I think small benchmarks will likely be much slower in Mu since Python probably has optimized primitives for the common things whereas Mu is still (naïvely) interpreted. On larger apps I think the gap might come down, since Python will start relying more on unoptimized primitives. But I should probably measure at some point..
(2) Lol. I actually modeled Mu's on JVM to some extent, so it's intended to be a better replacement of that layer of the stack, something that compiles down to native rather than relying on a bytecode interpreter, and also something that is designed with higher-order functional programming in mind, as well as generics out of the box (so no type erasure and so on).
Thanks for letting me know my idea finally got across. I was massively under-estimating its subtlety.