A huge part of what I love about working at 37signals is freedom. Freedom to say what I want and swear when I will. Freedom to pick any course I see fit. Freedom to try crazy things. Invariably, those freedoms would be curbed if we were owned by some big company.
If the whole goal is to just sell the thing I already have and love to start exactly the same thing again, then it doesn't make any sense to me. Why not just earn my way to prosperity rather than depending on a single golden benefactor to anoint me wealth?
Jason and I are already at the point where we don't have to work, we choose to work. The joy I derive from working at 37signals much surpass the expected joy of being able to afford a private jet or any other 10-digit luxury.
I don't know about that. It's not necessarily a sign of failure when the founders leave, and it may actually be a good thing in the long run. You want the founders around long enough to ensure that the business you bought gets integrated into your operations and company culture, and once that is done the founders should be free to leave if they choose. It may be a less desirable situation for the founders, but that may be due more to them being founder types (plus suddenly having a lot of cash ) rather than employee types. The other approach is to buy the company but have the founders run it as they did before with little interference from the acquiring company (e.g. Berkshire Hathaway).
That's why if I ever sell my business, I won't be part of the package. I never want to work for anyone else, ever again.
What I do state is that I understand DHH's perspective of wanting continuous rewarding work with total control of his business over a single pay day and subsequent buyout, even if that buyout is for a value greater than the business' current profits. In other words, his business is literally priceless in his mind because it gives his life meaning, something a pile of cash and no control over his creative work (which he clearly seems to believe is the best idea he's had and may ever have, in his life) does not.
I think we're looking at the hypothetical scenario from two different perspectives. Your's is arguably more realistic, in that you're right, if 37signals was bought out it's unlikely that DHH would be out of a job. And even if he was he could go on to create "38signals". My hypothetical scenario is based more on the idea of "sell to go sit on a beach for the rest of your life". That's to say, you would sell the business for a big pay day explicitly so you would not have to work anymore.
It's silly to make this particular business so central. As stated, he can sell it off and just start another shop that does the same thing. There is a lot of great work available for rich people -- they can start any business they want, they can become philanthropists and spend all day giving their money away.
If DHH sold 37s in a good deal, he'd have a lot more options for not only himself, but the future of his companies and all of their employees, and almost no meaningful restrictions not directly related to the properties associated with 37s.
It's really hard to convince people that that's a bad deal, because frankly it's not. Sell 37s and make something new; it can even do the same stuff, just has to be named differently.
I'm really not seeing how this would be a loss if it was done right.
"In other words, his business is literally priceless in his mind because it gives his life meaning..."
I did not say "...it is the only thing in DHH's life that gives his life meaning..." I seriously doubt that 37signals is so central to DHH's existence (or any member of 37signals) that removing it from their life would prevent them from moving on.
I just responded to Calacanis with a similar point, but essentially I believe you are looking at business as a method to maximize _money_. My point is that perhaps when we talk about maximizing _profit_, profit can be defined as more than money.
How many people acquire businesses just to push their founders out? Most aren't interested in that; they obviously respect or at least fear what the founder(s) were doing, or they wouldn't have bought their company. It's perfectly likely that DHH could keep on at 37signals after an acquisition.
However, in the case where the buyer just boarded the place up or pushed out the staff or whatever, who cares? DHH can go start 38signals and keep doing "valuable, profitable and rewarding" work.
Good work and good money aren't necessarily mutually exclusive.