News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Einstein: The Negro Question (1946) by Aoyagi on Sunday July 10, 2016 @07:04AM (#12065228)
I don't see how opening a glove box for a cop to look in is unreasonable.
Re:Einstein: The Negro Question (1946) by dgacmu on Sunday July 10, 2016 @01:47PM (#12066400)
He had no reason to look in there (no probable cause). It's going on a fishing expedition, and it's the start of the chain of events that leads to the "if you look hard enough, everybody's guilty of something" problem. The law is very clear that under the circumstances, the officer had no right to _compel_ me to let him look. If he had, anything he found as a result of the search would be inadmissible in court. But it's entirely within his right to ask, and if I voluntarily comply, then anything he finds can be used as evidence.

Here's an example with a fairly good discussion about what the police can and can't do, and under what circumstances, during a traffic stop: http://criminal.lawyers.com/traffic-violations/unlawful-vehi...

The problem is that "voluntary compliance" is very slippery (when you think of refusing a cop's request for something like that, do you imagine that there might be retribution? You might -- and if you're not in a relative position of power, it's almost certainly on your mind.) It's therefore easier for some people to assert their rights than for others, and that can lead to very unequal protection under the law.

Re:Einstein: The Negro Question (1946) by Aoyagi on Monday July 11, 2016 @03:33AM (#12069432)
No reason to look there? How do you know that? You think you, with your behaviour, can't be described as "acting suspiciously"? With that logic you might as well say he had no reason to stop you. Or to stop anyone unless the police officer has a very concrete reason for doing so. In other words, by your logic, routine traffic stops something you don't have to comply with at all.
Re:Einstein: The Negro Question (1946) by dgacmu on Monday July 11, 2016 @07:27PM (#12075591)
Goodness, you're full of unfounded assumptions. You also seem unfamiliar with American jurisprudence and the basics of constitutional law - I assume you're not local?

First of all, he did have no reason to stop me in particular -- it was a DUI checkpoint, and they were stopping everyone. DUI checkpoints are perfectly legit, but don't provide a basis for reasonable suspicion to search anyone thus stopped. (They were challenged, but deemed constitutional). Routine traffic stops are based upon an officer's observation of the law being broken, which provides a clear basis for stopping someone.

You seem to be arguing a strawman that I'm not presenting (that this is a slippery slope that leads to nobody obeying lawful orders).

But you are right on one thing: The police don't have the right to stop people unless they have a good reason to do so. This is legally well-established. See, for example, Delaware v. Prouse: https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/440/648

DUI checkpoints that are pre-announced and publicized are a valid reason to stop people. Observation of breaking the law, even in minor ways, is another. A broken taillight is sufficient, as is speeding. A license plate scan showing that there's an outstanding warrant - stop away.

But when it comes to expanding the search from a routine traffic stop, the 4th amendment guarantees the right to be free from _unreasonable_ search and seizure. Not from any search and seizure, but from searches and seizures lacking a reasonable basis and in which the search-ee has a reasonable expectation of privacy:

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/fourth_amendment

Note also that simple "nervousness" is a poor justification for expanding the scope of a stop and search (see State v. Moore, 4th circuit, 2013) http://www.judicial.state.sc.us/opinions/HTMLFiles/COA/5160....

Because of this, a police officer typically doesn't have reasonable suspicion to search your car if they just pull you over at a routine stop. (Obviously, if they see something suspicious -- open container, bag of pot, gun, whatever -- that provides a basis for further search.) But they're legally entitled to ask your permission to dig more -- and that's the behavior I object to, because it unfairly stacks the deck against people less aware of their specific rights under the situation and able to defend themselves legally.

Re:Einstein: The Negro Question (1946) by Aoyagi on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @05:22AM (#12077744)
In other words, yes , I was right. You think you're the one who can set what is reasonable, what is a good justification, and when can an officer be suspicious. Thanks for clearing that up.

Again, I'm not surprised American police acts the way they sometime act when they have to deal with the likes of you. Opening the glove box isn't an unreasonable request on any level.

And yes, I'm fully aware of American culture of "muh rights".

Re:Einstein: The Negro Question (1946) by Nadya on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @11:25AM (#12079798)
> Opening the glove box isn't an unreasonable request on any level.

You have the wrong definition of "unreasonable request". It isn't that it is difficult to open the glove box and thus is an "unreasonable request due to difficulty of compliance". It is unreasonable because they lack reason to open the glove box and have no right to search it. ("muh rights", and for damned good reasons)

dgacmu gave you legal cases (possibly precedent setting cases?) and you ignored that as if dgacmu set the limits and constraints of the law.

Re:Einstein: The Negro Question (1946) by Aoyagi on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @12:35PM (#12080448)
Again, by that logic, any random checks, including DUI checks, are unacceptable. That's what the first link is partially about. Second link is the 4th amendment and third link is an irrelevant opinion that doesn't even open from my end. All of that only supports the theory that dgacmu is one of those amusing "sovereign citizens" who treat the police like nuisance.

So yes, I ignored those links. And a lot of nonsense in that post.

Edit: I did learn that random stops are mostly illegal though. What a country to be a cop in. Now I'm doubly not surprised why American police acts the way they sometimes act.

Re:Einstein: The Negro Question (1946) by dgacmu on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @04:55PM (#12082222)
The amusing bit is that you can't tell the difference between someone who believes strongly that everyone (police and citizens) should follow the law, and the soverign citizen adherents, who believe [1]:

"that they are answerable only to their particular interpretation of the common law and are not subject to any statutes or proceedings at the federal, state, or municipal levels"

The soverign citizens live in a delusional world that wants to pretend that our judicial system has no say over them. Their beliefs and actions range from the mildly worrisome to outright domestic terrorism.

I live in a world in which I believe that understanding one's rights, responsibilities, and limits within our judicial system is important. And also that understanding why we have those laws is useful - a lesson you seem intent to ignore.

There are historical reasons for the powers granted to the police, and the limitations placed on those powers, primarily with an eye towards balancing the need to protect the populace as a whole while preventing specific abuses of power.

Here's one example: https://www.aclu.org/news/aclu-files-suit-stop-racial-profil...

(Note: The ACLU won, and the police were fined $2,000 for engaging in illegal racial profiling.)

It's hard to appreciate that case without the context, which is that this behavior was happening _constantly_ in this area of Utah, and in several other areas of the country:

https://www.utahbar.org/utah-bar-journal/article/a-problem-o...

If you can't understand that both citizens, politicians, the military, and police need to operate within a well-defined legal framework, I worry for you. When the Czech Police conspired to expel Romani from housing in Bohumin in 2005, including _cutting off their hot water supply in winter_, the same laws that limit the actions the police can take were the the same laws that eventually led to a remedy of the situation and a fine against the town. The same kinds of restrictive laws, in this case against using the military to spy on civilians, led to the resignation of Petr Necas. Or perhaps you're in the camp that believes "if you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear"? [2] After all, Necas' ex-wife had committed the horrible crime of not wanting to be married to him, so clearly deserved surveillance. Lest you think I'm picking on the Czech Republic, do recall that the Watergate scandal took down Nixon in the US, for similar abuses of official power.

We grant power to the police because people are imperfect, and sometimes break the law in ways that endanger or harm others. We place limitations on the power of the police because police are human too.

fin.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_citizen_movement [2] http://jacquesmattheij.com/if-you-have-nothing-to-hide

Re:Einstein: The Negro Question (1946) by dgacmu on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @11:08AM (#12079645)
"the likes of you" - yes, indeed. You're making some pretty big generalizations from behind that monitor of yours.

You seem to be aware of a particular, negative stereotype of the culture, but you're woefully ignorant of the laws and their history, so why are you continuing in the debate? You're making assumptions about my behavior with the police based upon my factual statements about the limits on police powers for search and seizure.

(for your edification: Had the officer had a reasonable suspicion, he wouldn't have needed to ask permission. In that case, it would have been an _order_, and regardless of whether it's lawful, when it happens, you follow an _order_ from a cop, and fix it up later in court.)

I'm done - you seem to have a strange stereotype of americans that puts anyone with beliefs that differ from yours in the "gun totin' amemdment hollerin' crazy" camp. You may find it more useful to stereotype me as an ACLU (google it)-donating, left-leaning liberal that comes from a family of law professors, and believes that a constitutional protections are a cornerstone of guaranteeing equal protection under the law. Without that, it's too easy for one sort of justice to be administered to the wealthy (and white), and another sort to be administered to everyone else.

Re:Einstein: The Negro Question (1946) by Aoyagi on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @12:22PM (#12080326)
I'm not making any assumptions mate. You said, multiple times, that you deny doing anything but what you absolutely must. Clearly just out of principle. That falls right into that stereotype. And that's behaviour I find disgusting regardless of your "freedoms".