News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by axod on Saturday March 20, 2010 @11:40AM (#1206486)
nice quote when they talk about Facebook

DHH: "... begging for advertising crumbs which these companies are essentially doing..."

Really odd perspective to have. Why is charging users directly any better? Online advertising expenditure is slightly more than crumbs.

Also I'm pretty sure total advertising expenditure online is massively more than people paying for subscription/services online.

Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by aditya on Saturday March 20, 2010 @11:51AM (#1206500)
Because when someone pays you directly, you're offering them something they value and would pay for rather than invading their brain with ads that they don't want to see?
Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by axod on Saturday March 20, 2010 @12:00PM (#1206515)
It works for some things. But charging users money to use facebook/twitter/most websites just wouldn't work.
Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by mquander on Saturday March 20, 2010 @01:16PM (#1206614)
There's no good fundamental reason why it wouldn't work. The only reasons are cultural (people like getting things for "free", especially on the internet) and technical (you have to dig out your credit card, sign up with it, and trust Facebook not to screw you, in order to pay them a dollar a month.)
Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by ericd on Saturday March 20, 2010 @02:34PM (#1206753)
Charging for things works best in areas where there are weak or no network effects. In something like facebook, having half of the customer base drop out would be disasterous, because those remaining are left with a worse product - having all of their friends on it is one of the strongest features.

In small business software a la 37 signals, you don't care how many other customers are there except for the vetting it provides.

In landgrabs in a high network-effect area, you can't afford to charge more than one's competitors. Hence, advertising.

Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by axod on Saturday March 20, 2010 @01:23PM (#1206621)
I disagree. The reasons are more straightforward. If there's a choice between a paid website, and a free website, the free one will win out. And advertising means you can offer users something for 'free'.

So lets say google switched to charging users for access to their search engine, a competitor would just popup that was 'free', and everyone would use that instead.

Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by mquander on Saturday March 20, 2010 @01:34PM (#1206647)
Well, I agree. That's what I meant to say when I referred to the cultural reason; since free alternatives always appear, people always expect a good free version to be available, and are even more hesitant to pay. However, I don't think that's a good place for us to be.

Firstly, it remains to be seen whether it's technically sustainable; if ad blockers continue to become more mainstream and more sophisticated, ads will start bringing in less and less money. Secondly, I think that many non-ad-blocking users are making a poor choice when they choose an ad-supported free version, because it's very hard to evaluate the costs to you of having ads on content. It puts a mental burden on you, wastes your time, and may (invisibly to you) cause you to make poor purchasing decisions later. Those are all real costs, but it's impossible for you to put a dollar value on them.

Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by axod on Saturday March 20, 2010 @02:19PM (#1206717)
>> "Firstly, it remains to be seen whether it's technically sustainable; if ad blockers continue to become more mainstream and more sophisticated, ads will start bringing in less and less money."

It's been rising steadily for 10+ years :/

Advertising in general has been pretty strong for 100+ years.

I doubt that'll change in our lifetimes. Advertisers always want to get their message to audiences, audiences always want to hear about new products. It's a pretty safe bet.

Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by davidw on Saturday March 20, 2010 @02:12PM (#1206710)
Whether we think that's a good place to be or not does not really matter. What matters are the underlying economics, which seem to pretty much continuously push in the direction of free services.
Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by runevault on Saturday March 20, 2010 @11:51AM (#1206498)
When you introducing advertising, you have two sets of users, the advertisers who are your income stream, and the users who you need to keep around to make the advertisers happy. If you have directly paying users, you only have to worry about making those users happy, and you know you have something people really can't do without easily, because they are willing to pay their hard earned money for it, since many people value money more than time, or so it appears based on the popularity of free services.
Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by axod on Saturday March 20, 2010 @12:01PM (#1206518)
If users didn't find advertising useful, they wouldn't click on them. So the two forces aren't opposing.
Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by mquander on Saturday March 20, 2010 @01:27PM (#1206631)
Well, that's just not true. When I don't have an ad blocker, I click on ads just by accident once in a while, since many are so intrusive. Also, ads are often tremendously misleading, and will try their hardest to fool you into imagining that they are useful without actually being useful; that's how they make money.
Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by axod on Saturday March 20, 2010 @01:43PM (#1206662)
I disagree.

Lets say for the sake of argument that people only clicked on ads by accident. Then no clicks would convert, advertisers would pull the ads, or drastically reduce payouts.

Advertisers only pay, when advertising works - eg converts to a sale/signup/etc

Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by mquander on Saturday March 20, 2010 @01:53PM (#1206680)
It really is my strong suspicion that the majority of conversions are due to misleading users, though. Let's divide ads into two categories:

- "Punch the monkey for herbal supplements." There are a lot of ads for gimmick products or products that simply don't work well at all. (Some are pure scams, and some just advertise terrible things, but we might as well lump them all together.) People still buy them, because people are credulous.

- Targeted ads for useful products. On Stack Overflow right now I see an ad for some tool that analyzes log files and spits out metrics and data. That sounds pretty useful, but the ad is not helping me make an informed decision. If I decided right now to buy that product, even if it worked for me, the ad would not have served me well. The better way to buy things is to decide what you need, make an independent survey of the products available to you, and figure out which one is best via reviews, experts, comments, specs. Successful ads encourage you to short-circuit this process and just pick something, which I don't think is a positive thing.

Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by telemachos on Saturday March 20, 2010 @01:53PM (#1206679)
You seem to have ignored a key part of the parent's argument: ads often mislead people. So the fact that they make a sale doesn't show that they are 'useful' for a reasonable definition of useful.
Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by axod on Saturday March 20, 2010 @02:55PM (#1206791)
There are so many adverts that "often" really needs to be backed up with hard data.
Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by telemachos on Saturday March 20, 2010 @03:26PM (#1206842)
Our worldviews seem so completely different that we're probably talking past each other.

Case in point: I don't know how to respond to someone who requests data to establish that advertising is based on manipulation. You may as well be speaking Martian to me. (My immediate response - after sputtering - is, more or less, "It's advertising. Look at some.")

Let me stress, I'm not saying this as a put-down or any kind of argument in proof of anything. I'm simply trying to express in words my jaw dropping when I read your response.

Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by axod on Saturday March 20, 2010 @04:06PM (#1206908)
Advertising is just "information". :/ and information 'manipulates' people who consume it. But I'm not sure why you consider that a bad thing.

Probably about half the posts on HN are 'adverts'. They are posts that have a message, urging us, the readers, to consider this information and possibly act on it. That's an advert.

Your previous point "Ads often mislead people"...

News often misleads people. People often mislead other people. It's not unique to advertising by any means.

Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by alayne on Saturday March 20, 2010 @01:44PM (#1206665)
DHH has talked before about his opposition to ad-based businesses. It is bread crumbs on a per user basis. That means you need a huge number of eyeballs to profit. Building a system so large and popular that it gets that many users is difficult and there is a lottery factor.

On the moral side, people don't like advertising. That's the seamy underbelly of Google; they are constantly playing this game of how much advertising pain will people endure for their free services. You know, maybe stoplights could flash some adsense ads relevant to the types of passing vehicles to cover infrastructure costs. I don't want to live in adsense world.

Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by axod on Saturday March 20, 2010 @02:34PM (#1206752)
It's a niche viewpoint. I do want to live in an adsense world, as do most users. They find adverts useful.

>> "DHH has talked before about his opposition to ad-based businesses. It is bread crumbs on a per user basis. That means you need a huge number of eyeballs to profit. Building a system so large and popular that it gets that many users is difficult and there is a lottery factor."

I think basically, it's 'harder'. It's a harder problem to solve. But really, you can setup a profitable website in the right niche earning good money from advertising easily without requiring large number of eyeballs.

Re:DHH vs. Calacanis on This Week in Startups by armandososa on Sunday March 21, 2010 @02:18AM (#1207611)
People don't like advertising? I think it is an unfair generalization. People love free stuff and are willing to endure advertising because they love free stuff.

The charge upfront idea is great for some business but let's be honest: if every website did that and the whole internet was behind a paywall the web would die.