As for page views option, that wouldn't work either. I, personally, don't do more than 10 page views a day and most of my friends are the same. I suspect many people just check their profile, answer wall posts or messages, look at some apps and log out. There is not much there that can hold your attention.
All Facebook can really do now is pray that people still find it interesting. I think the Beacon was their attempt at monetizing the interest. That got shut down, so they're SOL.
I suspect many people spend hours and hours on it. These are the ones who should, perhaps, be urged to pay. The light users are more likely to leave on any harassment.
Possibly, because it wouldn't happen in isolation. Some still-free FB competitor would make a huge effort to get all the users who didn't want to pay, get most of them, and then most of the paying users would leave FB because their friends had.
I think that they think that charging for access would be a disaster
Would it be a total collapse? If advertising isn't working, well...