Set aside the reciprocal nature of racism and criminality and acknowledge the raw demographic reality of police encounters in major cities. It seems clear to me that yes, police officers are under far too much cognitive strain to accurately judge threats. Basic human cognitive limitations ensure that police will continue to prejudge risk through race.
To me, that, coupled with the fact that police encounters with strangers are far, far less dangerous than police training and culture mythologizes them to be, suggests a straightforward solution: disarm most police officers.
I wrote more about that here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12057079
(If you feel the need to object, please read that before assuming you know what my recommendation is from its brief summary here).
It generally works in EU countries, but a lot is different there.
What I reject though is you suggesting my comment is mean spirited. The statements you feel are offensive are just facts as far as we can tell today. You would attack my statements instead of me personally if what I wrote was obviously wrong.
Regarding the linked comment:
> Most (not all) suspects who shoot at cops aren't doing it out of spite, but instead of out self-preservation.
How do you know this? Your comment is based on this being true, because if it were otherwise there would be no way your proposal could work. In that case disarmed police officers would continue to get shot but now without being able to defend themselves.
Stats are tricky. I can forgive a serving officer not understanding the stats, and falling victim to a cognitive bias.
But you have the benefits of understanding stats, and knowing about bias. You don't have any excuse for making such mistakes.
By the way, I don't need an excuse for having an opinion.
You seem to presume that are you holding the moral high ground allowing you to attack me (insinuating I am plain stupid) without even needing to deliver any facts that prove me wrong.
You can see whatever pattern or proof you want if you look at the numbers long enough, to serve any narrative, to rationalize any opinon.
> You can see whatever pattern or proof you want if you look at the numbers long enough, to serve any narrative, to rationalize any opinon.
In most Western countries the governments release stats about crimes committed by type and by citizenship or in case of the US by race.
I don't have to search for a pattern there that fits a "narrative", the statistics bluntly state which race commits most crimes in different categories.
If you don't like what these government stats show please feel free to share with us why you believe that we shouldn't use these stats. But I'm not interested in trading insults, so please keep the discussion civil and based on facts.
Sorry, when you said ...
> > Just look at these statistics
... I thought you weren't giving an opinion, but basing your argument in facts.
Just look at these statistics and then consider how a police officer would feel when dealing with a black person that shows any kind of aggression, considering that most homicides are committed by blacks. (even though they are a minority)
The police officer wants to survive too.
Of course there are cases of excessive and criminal use of force by the police, but their general perception and caution when dealing with blacks will never change as long as this minority continues to commit most crimes.