In the US, police forces are local and independent in much the same way that DAs are. Hence, there's not really a way at a federal or even state level to correct the prosecutorial/enforcement dynamic that's driving a lot of the problems.
Outside of merging precincts to create larger areas of oversight, training, and policy parity, it's a really hard sell to make to all of the thousands of police organizations independently and pretty difficult to monitor and enforce.
I don't even think police unions, as effective as they are at organizing internal activities, would be successful in getting blanket reforms to stick. The changes, as currently structured, have got to be from within.
In the USA, especially in certain parts such as suburban Michigan, where my wife is from, there are a huge number of guns being carried all around at all times. But I don't feel the least bit unsafe; to the contrary, I like knowing that the people I'm meeting or hanging out with are able to defend the group without our having to call the police.
I assert that, at this moment in history in the USA, with gun ownership being what it is and police militarization having gone so far, disarming police will bring greater peace than disarming non-police.
Really? It's not hard to understand at all.
That you might have a gun, doesn't really assuage the fear that some normal person in a bad mood might pull their gun on you.
I live in Canada. Cops are chill here. They are not skittish or scared they might get shot.
When cops pull me over in some places in the US, they act like a goddam swat team.
Yes you do. There some seriously bad areas in American cities. Places where you can get mugged, robbed, assulted or murdered by virtue of just being there.
Cops do die on the job.
There's over a million police in the US.
Last year less than 200 US officers died on the job.
I tried to find some stats on the number of civilians killed by police but those numbers are hard to pin down. In terms of blacks killed by police the numbers vary between 300 and 700[1]. I suppose this number is irrelevant because it is a tiny percentage of the total population?
[1]http://www.cbc.ca/news/trending/number-of-black-people-kille...
I think police itself is hard to fix, because the system is so federated. There is nobody, who can just say: "Alright, now the standards are a, b and c."