Re:Bitcoin block reward is halving in less than 2 hours
by dublinben on Saturday July 09, 2016 @02:30PM
(#12062630)
That's a pretty big "if." There is currently a crisis over block size that has failed to reach any consensus. It's unlikely that any fundamental feature of Bitcoin will ever be allowed to change.
Re:Bitcoin block reward is halving in less than 2 hours
by nadaviv on Sunday July 10, 2016 @11:47AM
(#12065958)
There is no crisis, consensus for the block size debate was reached quite a long time ago. The development community is in final stages of testing and QA for segregated witness, which would ~double the capacity of the network.
Also, I would not consider the divisibility of bitcoins as a fundamental feature of Bitcoin. Compared to the block size debate (which has effects on the decentralization of the network), divisibility is a pretty straightforward change that has little (none?) drawbacks and should reach consensus pretty easily.
Re:Bitcoin block reward is halving in less than 2 hours
by JoshTriplett on Sunday July 10, 2016 @03:55PM
(#12067003)
> The development community is in final stages of testing and QA for segregated witness, which would ~double the capacity of the network.
A factor of two or four doesn't really solve the problem, it just puts off the problem. (The same thing goes for minor block size changes, really.) What will happen when the network needs 100x capacity?
Re:Bitcoin block reward is halving in less than 2 hours
by gnaritas on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @06:57PM
(#12090379)
It solves it for now, which tends to be how democracies solve problems, which is what bitcoin is. Fixing it permanently is how an engineer thinks, but that style of thinking doesn't work in a consensus network full of non-engineers. Kicking the can down the road is inherent to community based solutions.
However, if the value of one satoshi ever grew large enough that people wanted to subdivide it, it'd be possible to migrate to a smaller division by consensus, by adding support in miners and clients, advertising that support without using it, and migrating when enough of those advertised the support.