I wonder how they'd do if they were more open about it. "You're getting Gmail for free because we read your email and advertise to you. However, if you want to pay for a premium account (or Google Apps for Work) then we won't advertise to you, won't read your email and we'll even make end-to-end encryption easy and convenient".
I mean, it seems like a good compromise. I'd be happier with the rampant advertising and profiling going on if it was only for signed-in users and everyone was given the choice - use it for free or pay and get guaranteed privacy and no ads.
Here it is (google as an example only, simplified) the answer:
* Put two googles side by side. competing.
* one is a current one, earning money from ads on you being product, and keeping it under the radar (although in fine print etc etc)
* second is the one devised: premium accounts plus free w/ads
* wait 5 years and observe by market efficiency evolution which of the (competing) companies wins. The first one. In this specific scenario, the second loses because time and money spent on 'premium accounts' will not be compensated by revenues from it. While at the same time, the first google, spending this capital difference purely on the ads department will make its ads department (here 100% of it) much better than ads part in second company. hereby winning on the market.
In general (as the google example is SIMPLIFIED, due to the alphabet scale. Please don't use google apps FOR WORK (emphasis mine ;) as an counter example - it's B2B product :) it is because: we, humans, don't like companies who use fine print etc, yet those companies win case by case with the 'moral, pure pricing and fine ethics' companies BECAUSE OF BIASES AND ERRORS (+) OF HUMAN BRAINS during choice making shopping, exploited day by day.
Thats why.
(+) read stupidity also known why-I-buy-overpriced-sweets-at-checkout ;)
Then he'll be referred to a human, who may or may not understand sarcasm, jokes, or hyperbole?
This is exactly why these companies don't want to be more transparent unless they absolutely have to (like what the EU is doing to Google), but it really should be more regulated by governments, because I think it's a very "fair" thing to do - sharing everything you're doing with someone's info. It's not about restricting the data collection through regulation, just being transparent about it. That might lead to less useful information for the data collectors, but people should be informed and it should trump everything else.
I mean, a large number of people here do know that machines scan their email. In what manner do the majority act? That shows us the revealed preference.
If that's not the definition of an ad company then I don't know what is.
[1] - http://adage.com/article/digital/google-q4-2015-earnings/302...
You could go further and do something like, email sent by people to people is off-limits and will be end-to-end encrypted and not looked at - but (almost) all automatically generated email is fair game and will be processed. Google already does that with Google Now (and shows you your flights, package deliveries etc.). I really prefer them making more explicit what they look at and what not.
Shh, don't tell everyone about my next project. I think it can be done with images as well sending 5 of them for various demographic groups would be doable and should create enough noise (one tampon ad, a video game ad, an ad for amazon, a mountain dew ad, and a retirement plan ad for example). For those who care not for anonymity, but more for bandwidth they can opt out and only download the ad's they need.
Facebook can do fine without that information: they have more information than they can develop ad services for at the moment; they could use a lot more engineers though. The goodwill from the dev community in allowing appropriate targeting is far more important to them.
Two good examples being location and language: you can advertise for people in a certain place or who speak a certain language, but there are many unserved combinations, like tourists, language minorities and commuters. In my case, I’d love to see ads on learning Swedish: Facebook can see some of my friends speak it, and this is new.
Source: worked for Fb, but in Engagement, not the Ads team; offered a lot of targeting suggestions, but most where “presumably not the biggest opportunities (they) could work on”. At Facebook’s scale, we are talking really big numbers.
Yeah, that whole Bill of Rights thing just needs to go away, right?
The same reason Gmail can't work with end-to-end encryption--they want to advertise at you based on message content.
I highly doubt there is any government intervention in FB's business strategy, but there seems to be plenty of cooperation after the business decisions are made. (The same is largely true with Microsoft, Google, and yes, even Apple.) It's not really a conspiracy, or a matter of paranoia--it's been very widely reported for a while now, and people just generally don't seem to give a shit (myself increasingly included).
EDIT: I do care. But I think (a) people need to take privacy into their own hands, since companies will never be incentivized to do it and (b) we've entered a new cultural era, where the levels of privacy enjoyed in the past are no longer socially normal.