Re:Facebook Messenger begins testing end-to-end encryption u...
by yoz-y on Friday July 08, 2016 @09:06AM
(#12055183)
They have taken exactly the same approach as Google with the Allo service. This is most probably done because people want to use Chat Bots and services and these do not work with E2E encryption. Well they could work but it would be dishonest branding as the messages would leak.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Facebook Messenger begins testing end-to-end encryption u...
by nxzero on Friday July 08, 2016 @09:47AM
(#12055416)
>> "Chat Bots and services and these do not work with E2E encryption"
It might be true that FB adding E2E breaks existing bots, but it's false that it breaks that ability to use bots on FB.
Re:Facebook Messenger begins testing end-to-end encryption u...
by yoz-y on Friday July 08, 2016 @12:54PM
(#12056913)
It could work but as I said it would be dishonest. If a bot can read your messages then you have to trust a third party to not leak/store them. I believe that he goal of E2E encryption is to remove the need to trust somebody. (Of course you still have to trust FB that they do not backdoor or hinder the encryption but you do not have to trust the third parties)
Re:Facebook Messenger begins testing end-to-end encryption u...
by nxzero on Friday July 08, 2016 @05:21PM
(#12058733)
With a chatbot you are chatting with the bot.
All the bot needs to is be able to use the Signal E2E protocol to establish key & message exchanges.
Nothing dishonest about this and nothing different than existing bots other than one uses E2E and one does not.
Re:Facebook Messenger begins testing end-to-end encryption u...
by yoz-y on Monday July 11, 2016 @05:55AM
(#12069963)
I do not speak of chatbots such as Cleverbot. For example your bot will listen to your messages and provide contextual information, such as theatres airing a movie you are currently talking about. The bot also probably needs to keep track of the context, which probably means keeping the chat history for some time. In order to learn the chatbot needs to keep the history forever and scan it for ML purposes. All of these mean that the bot has to keep the history somewhere unencrypted, basically nullifying the benefit of E2E.