News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why most people don't like jazz by CodeMage on Friday March 19, 2010 @05:10PM (#1205295)
Isn't it important to define success conditions before throwing around words like "failure"? Usually it's considered two or more people "fail at conversation" if they don't manage to:

1) understand what others are trying to convey

2) make others understand what they're trying to convey

Even given that definition, it's questionable whether the listener or the speaker failed, if the listener does not understand the speaker's language. Was it acceptable to expect the listener to understand it?

Without going into any further details, my point is that I think your metaphor is inadequate, basically because it implies that the artist's intention is invariable to have his or her art appreciated by as many people as possible.

Re:Why most people don't like jazz by blueben on Sunday March 21, 2010 @02:23PM (#1208327)
Two generations of people understood the conversation of Jazz. So yes, it is reasonable to expect another generation to also participate in that conversation. Unfortunately, that new generation has lost something.