It won't guarantee it, just tires to size things (eden space, survivor spaces) and time things to meet its target.
But it's a fickle beast. And usually it requires a lot of tinkering with the code for it to be able to meet it. And then it's easier to disable ergonomics, set fixed sizes, and just enjoy how blazingly fast CMS is, restart the app every few weeks (CMS heap fragmentation), and try G1 with every new point release, maybe finally it beats CMS.
1. It uses about an order of magnitude less memory than Java.
2. It openly proclaims <10ms STW pauses for GC.
Google wrote a paper comparing C++, Java, Scala, and Go and definitely did not find that (https://days2011.scala-lang.org/sites/days2011/files/ws3-1-H...).
I like Go and it has many wonderful qualities. Still, it's important to be realistic.
Programs holding GBs of data in arrays would look much closer, though, I imagine, as the overhead would be dwarfed by the data itself.
https://www.cs.virginia.edu/kim/publicity/pldi09tutorials/me...
http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/189542/is-mem...
http://stackoverflow.com/questions/5673388/what-is-the-small...
For me using Java 1.8 the number is around 1.5MB. Something similar in Go is 60KB
Do you know of any real-world examples where the lack of compaction is impacting usage of Go ?
That's why you don't do it often.
> Do you know of any real-world examples where the lack of compaction is impacting usage of Go ?
The biggest problem with all nongenerational GCs, including Go's, is lack of bump allocation in the nursery. You really want a two-space copying collector (or a single-space one) so that allocation in the nursery can be reduced to 3 or 4 machine instructions. By allowing fragmentation in the nursery, Go pays a heavy cost in allocation performance relative to HotSpot.
You need to do it when you become too fragmented (or suffer the same potentially poor allocation performance as Go), how often that happens largely depends on what the application is doing.
>including Go's, is lack of bump allocation in the nursery.
Yes, but as I recall this is in the future roadmap for consideration/attempt.
And again, as with everything it's not a silver bullet, as you sacrifice the high cost of promotion (again expensive moving of memory) in order to have very fast allocations while the nursery isn't fragmented or full.
>Go pays a heavy cost in allocation performance relative to HotSpot.
But not the cost of compaction/promoting, which are also heavy when they need to be performed.
That said, I personally believe a bump allocator with generational copying will be a 'net win' if implemented in Go's GC, but all things considered I'd rather see some cold hard numbers confirming it.
Not according to the transactional collector proposal. By not unconditionally tenuring young objects, it sacrifices one of the main benefits of generational GC: bump allocation in the nursery.
> And again, as with everything it's not a silver bullet, as you sacrifice the high cost of promotion (again expensive moving of memory) in order to have very fast allocations while the nursery isn't fragmented or full.
You're questioning the generational hypothesis. Generational GC was invented in 1984. Whether generational GC works is something we've had over 30 years to figure out, and the answer has consistently been a resounding "yes, it works, and works well".
> all things considered I'd rather see some cold hard numbers confirming it.
Again, we have over 30 years of experience. Generational GC is not some new research idea that we have to try to see if it works. The odds that things will be different in Go than in the myriad of other languages that preceded it are incredibly slim.
That's hardly the end all of Go GC development, also as I understand it's not even certain it will be used in a Go release as it depends on it actually showing the benefits aren't just theorethical.
>Whether generational GC works is something we've had over 30 years to figure out, and the answer has consistently been a resounding "yes, it works, and works well".
This was not about generational GC's 'working' or not, it was if it is the best solution for the typical workloads of Go applications.
From what I understand, the upcoming transactional collector is written directly with Go's goroutines in mind.
I'm pretty skeptical that it will produce wins over a traditional generational GC. At best the "transactional hypothesis" will roughly approximate the generational hypothesis, without the primary benefit that truly generational GC gives you, namely bump allocation in the nursery. Time will tell.
Further, depending on your data access patterns you can see data access start to degrade over time as well because the memory locality is worse.
GC benchmarks are great at showing how well 1 part of memory management is behaving (ie the deallocation step) but it doesn't do much for talking about the other 2 parts, allocation and access.
That said, I use Go lang every day and the GC improvements to date have been great, especially given the kinds of memory patterns lots of the services I write have (small, short lived items that aren't really connected to each other). But there are definitely memory patterns where Hotspot will smoke the golang memory system and that doesn't begin to describe something like Zing.
And still I have heard the one of the best way to control GC in many trading systems where Zing might be popular is to just provision 100s of GBs of memory heap and simply restart server once trading day is over.
Now that I'm writing high throughput systems in go I use many of the same techniques that I did writing low latency systems on the JVM (arena allocation, memory locality, etc). This is because the other 2 parts of memory management, allocation and access, continue to be major drivers of performance even though the deallocation step is fundamentally different.
That is to say, GC times are not the only thing that matters when it comes to memory management and it is a relatively straightforward tradeoff between deallocation and allocation that the current golang GC is making.
Not sure how it could be done but having some numbers on this would be great.
"The results are only really meaningful together with a specification of how much memory was used. It is possible to trade memory for better time performance. This benchmark should be run in a 32 MB heap, though we don't currently know how to enforce that uniformly."
For some years, the benchmarks game did show an alternative task where memory was limited -- but only for half-a-dozen language implementations.
Figuring out an appropriate max heap size for each program was too hands-on trial and error.
"This is no substitute for real applications. No actual application is likely to behave in exactly this way. However, this benchmark was designed to be more representative of real applications than other Java GC benchmarks of which we are aware."
Java's GCs make no concrete claims because they scale from tiny to very large heaps with vastly different object populations and root set sizes.
Some java applications run with 100GB heaps or on 128-core NUMA machines with lots of threads.
10ms pause times are achievable with "modest" heap sizes (~single-digit GBs) if you have some cores to spare for a concurrent collector to do its work, well, concurrently.
If you don't have enough spare CPU time or have a larger heap or a workload without enough breathing room then it would be silly to make such guarantees.
Of course they could easily write "<10ms STW pauses. sometimes. read the fine print"