News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by landryraccoon on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @02:23PM (#12038421)
I think you mean lower expected value, no? The way you put it cash is strictly better in every way than options - both higher expectation and lower risk. According to you there's no upside to options relative to cash.
Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by jonknee on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @02:26PM (#12038438)
No, having your options be worth a lot is a very rare event. That's why they hand them out instead of giving you more money.
Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by bjacokes on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @07:25PM (#12040232)
The main reason that options are handed out is to compensate for below-market salaries, and the main reason salaries are below market is that the company wants to increase its runway. Some specific valuations or offers warrant cynicism, but remember that any startup with negative cash flow (even successful ones with near-market salaries) should be giving out equity to keep their salaries costs down.
Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by jonknee on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @10:35PM (#12040885)
Yes, but most of these companies fail and the options thus worthless. I mean it's great when it works out, but like lottery tickets they usually aren't worth the paper they are printed on.
Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by bjacokes on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @11:02PM (#12040946)
Right: startups give out options, and those options are likely to be worthless. Your previous comment, however, was also suggesting causation: startups give out options because they are likely to be worthless. That's certainly not the entire reason. Like I said, a startup doesn't want to pay market salary because it would effectively ~halve their cash runway versus shifting compensation towards equity.
Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by Retric on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @02:33PM (#12038503)
Generally companies hand out options because their expected value is Less than cash. Put another way, they could also just hand out stock instead of stock options.
Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by harryh on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @07:53PM (#12040334)
He's talking about expected value in the probability sense.

EV = payout * probability

So for cash:

EV = 150k (or whatever your salary is) * 100% (it's guaranteed)

For equity it might be:

EV = 1M * 10% = 100k

Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by mikeash on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @02:37PM (#12038538)
The upside is a non-zero chance of becoming filthy rich. Some people are willing to put up with a lower expected value in exchange for that chance. It's a fancy version of the lottery, which many people also play.
Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by jsprogrammer on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @03:58PM (#12039082)
You shouldn't be able to influence a lottery outcome. Presumably, you can influence share prices if you work for a company that you have an ownership claim on.
Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by madgar on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @08:45PM (#12040540)
Do you actually believe that as a non-founding employee you'll be able to make the difference between the company delivering "a life changing amount of money" to employees instead of the far more common outcome?

I guess the same type of mind that believes meritocracy really exists could believe such a thing...

Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by jsprogrammer on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @10:28PM (#12040869)
Do you believe companies can accomplish anything they envision, without employees? Or do you think employees are entirely fungible?

Does my last employer not have a large contract with Prudential, because of my work?

Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by madgar on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @09:29AM (#12042907)
> Or do you think employees are entirely fungible?

This is what every self-respecting capitalist believes and knows in their heart. Employees are resources. If a founder doesn't know that they will fail.

Maybe you thought startups were an exception and that startup employees are unique snowflakes but BigCo employees are drones?

> Does my last employer not have a large contract with Prudential, because of my work?

If that contract is what made the business viable, then the company must be completely fucked without you and be on their way to failure. If the contract didn't make a substantial difference in the company's outlook, then how does that relate to my point?

Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by landryraccoon on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @05:50PM (#12046115)
Have you worked at a small startup before?

> If that contract is what made the business viable, then the company must be completely fucked without you and be on their way to failure.

In any startup with <5 employees if an early employee leaves it's a huge risk to the company that may result in bankruptcy or failure of the company. Engineer #1 is as important as a founder in the startups I've worked at.

If there are 3 founders and 2 non-founder employees, then typically each employee is doing (approximately) 20% of the work. Not many small companies can just shrug off losing 20% of their workforce.

> This is what every self-respecting capitalist believes and knows in their heart. Employees are resources. If a founder doesn't know that they will fail.

I hate to be rude but WTF are you talking about? I've known several successful startup CEOs and they keep good employees close and well taken care of. For one thing, startups usually fail, so you're going to have to keep your good employees open to working with you on your next attempt, and if you keep treating them like slaves/resources they won't come with you to your next venture. Second, how are you going to recruit new talent if your reputation as a founder is that you treat your employees like interchangeable "resources"?

Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by jsprogrammer on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @01:27PM (#12044576)
It was a consulting firm trying to break in with a larger client, so they had to move to other projects. Last I saw, they were working on Android projects.

>Maybe you thought startups were an exception and that startup employees are unique snowflakes but BigCo employees are drones?

No, I just don't think anything can be done without people and that one person is not the same as another.

Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by sokoloff on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @11:39PM (#12041057)
"make the difference" alone? Probably not.

Did I "positively influence the outcome" in the company I work for? Almost assuredly.

Of course, this is coming from a mind which does basically believe in a meritocracy, so...

Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by sheepleherd on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @02:30PM (#12038487)
you are correct to point out the "flaw" in what s/he said.

I don't know the actual answer (and it would be difficult to convince me that anybody has all the data either) but many people "experienced" with startups believe that so many more options come out worthless that cash is strictly better, better expected return at lower risk.

however, in the same way that the freakonomics guys explain people playing state lotteries even thought they are "not worth it": state lotteries (and startups) offer some of the few chances that most people have to actually get rich, so even though they don't pay off on average, they are "the only way" and "worth it" to some people. Not claiming that these people have clear ideas about either expected values or risks involved, but they have clear ideas that "it's the only way". For workers at many skill levels, they may have a sense that in their industry they won't be too much worse off in the long run so why not take a shot.

Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by jessaustin on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @02:31PM (#12038492)
That's really a moot point, important only from a "risk neutral" standpoint. You've just discovered why risk-averse people don't work for startups.
Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by bradleyjg on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @02:34PM (#12038521)
You're assuming a utility function of someone that's either risk adverse or risk neutral. What happens when you plug in a risk seeker?
Re:Who pays when startup employees keep their equity? by YokoZar on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @03:38PM (#12038948)
They'd probably be better off with cash and gambling in some other fashion.