Re:Milgram experiment redone: crowd "tortures" man on fake T...
by bmm6o on Friday March 19, 2010 @07:03PM
(#1205523)
> [they] do not test the same thing, they are not the same,and do not at all display the same riguor
Ok, but I'm not sure who you're arguing with here. Is your beef with the word "experiment"? Nobody is submitting these results to a journal. If you prefer, call it a demonstration re-enacting a phenomenon that has been the subject of other experiments.
- The milgram experiment and this pseudo-experiment do not test the same thing, they are not the same,and do not at all display the same riguor. Hence you can't talk about them as the same experiment.
- The milgram experiment is a solid experiment, that has got solid criticisms too, but i'm not at all implying it was fake.