Re:"No Dashes Or Spaces" Hall of Shame
by pg on Friday March 19, 2010 @01:24AM
(#1203446)
Back in our Viaweb days this was my quick test for whether a competitor was worth taking seriously.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Let me play devil's advocate here. Users who are not tech-savvy or those who are new to using credit cards online might be afraid at each step that they do something wrong.
-Enter credit card!
-Uhm, I wonder if it means with spaces or with dashes or just the numbers, I hope the money won't go to the wrong place
If it says 'no dashes or spaces' at least it's clear and might be reassuring to the user that the designers have thought of the same thing as him/her, which sort of indicates that he/she is on the right track and hasn't screwed up yet.
I'm not saying this is good usability practice, but it would be interesting to test different versions for user reactions.
If that were the only issue, the instructions could always say "spaces are optional".
In that case there would still be different possible ways to enter it. "without dashes and spaces" makes it unambiguous. Again, I'm not claiming it's usable, but sometimes interface design can be counter-intuitive.
Did that actually bear out in which companies went on to be successful? It's an appealing notion, but I question it every time I run across a successful company that can't get it right.
I would expect that rule to be more reliable for startups than for large companies that can survive on mediocrity.
Yes, by competitors, I meant other startups building ecommerce software, not sites like Walmart. IIRC it
worked well.
Do you think it is a still good test today?
Re:"No Dashes Or Spaces" Hall of Shame
by pchristensen on Friday March 19, 2010 @12:58PM
(#1204555)
Probably - it's a good indication of thoroughness, user-orientation, consistent interface design, etc. All of these are crucial to new and growing businesses.