Re:Mozilla shouldn't copy Chrome's permission prompt for ext...
by Manishearth on Sunday July 03, 2016 @06:55AM
(#12025595)
Note that Firefox has had this process for years, for addons with far more power than what Chrome gets you. Sure, it is tedious and could be improved, but the model works.
Also, I don't think you will have to go through review for extensions not requesting dangerous permissions. For some definition of dangerous :)
(I wonder if both models could be implemented simultaneously -- unreviewed extensions with "use at own risk" warnings, and reviewed ones with fine-grained semantic permissions)
Sounds to me that the permissions prompt is doing exactly what it should be doing, informing users what the extension can do.
Sure it would be fun if there was a qualified code review process which could gather all necessary permissions from the code, but with bigger extensions this would take days or weeks to get right and unless you can get money out of your extension that is a long wait. Like, I've made couple extensions I've wanted and when I get them done and uploaded I just want to show them off to few friends and install it myself. These are very much spur of a moment things, if I had to wait through rounds and rounds of codereview and questions about my code I probably couldn't be arsed to create extensions.