> I want more research on this area, so it can be
> improved
Somehow it sounds more obviously ridiculous when you rephrase it and start looking for "solutions" to improving the intelligence of all white people.Small differences between very large, heterogenous populations gives you virtually no predictive power about individuals or how to help them, but do facilitate subtle and overt racism, however well-meaning it might be.
[1 SD is not a 'small difference'. (2 SD's if you compare to Ashkenazic Jews).]
> On what evidence can you say that more research
> won't/can't help
On what basis can you say it will? These studies have known drawbacks in that they serve as a rallying point for all sorts of discrimination masquerading as high-minded discourse, and we're yet to see a benefit so far, so the burden of proof here is on you.At least part of the problem here is given two children / job-applicants / defendants / whatever, who are absolutely identical in every way except for a specific cosmetic phenotype, what possible justification is there for treating them differently based on correlation between that phenotype and some other characteristic over a large population?
You're arguing for deliberate ignorance because reality is uncomfortable.
> At least part of the problem here is given two children / job-applicants / defendants / whatever, who are absolutely identical in every way except for a specific cosmetic phenotype, what possible justification is there for treating them differently based on correlation between that phenotype and some other characteristic over a large population?
If two people are identical in every observable way, and that single observable way indicates a strong difference between them, why wouldn't one differentiate based on that single observation? They are, after all, indifferentiable in every other way.
Indeed, mathematically speaking if one ignores the single useful datum you posit, then one will make worse decisions: if you have no other data and just flip a coin between greens and blues in your thought experiment a few posts back, then you will choose worse than if you bias your coin towards greens. That's just a fact; whether you choose to ignore it based on the discomfort it causes you is up to you.
> Are you justified in preferring to hire green people? No.
Why the heck wouldn't you be justified in preferring to hire people who are, on average, more intelligent and less violent?
> Are you justified in having greens-only policies? Of course not, that's not how averages work.
I agree — in the scenario, any individual blue might be preferable to the great mass of greens.
> Is there any basis for any kind of segregation? Any basis for any color-based policies? No … It's precisely because there's almost no practical use for studies like these
There's no practical use that you care to put into practice. What you're arguing for is categories of 'forbidden knowledge': stuff that everyone agrees to ignore, because its truth is too discomforting. That seems a bit childish to me: one of the hallmarks of maturity is coming to terms with uncomfortable knowledge.
Besides, here's one practical use for such a study: in your example, if blues were a much higher proportion of the prison population than they are of society at large, knowing that they are less intelligent and more violent on average is information which can help one determine if that is fair or not.
> What you're arguing for is
> categories of 'forbidden
> knowledge'
No, I'm expressly calling attempting to make useful decisions on individuals based on small differences in wider populations illogical and non-rational. It would not be difficult to model this mathematically. > Why the heck wouldn't you be
> justified in preferring to
> hire people who are, on
> average, more intelligent
> and less violent?
Because that knowledge tells you absolutely nothing about any given individual.You can't know the heart of any man: all you can do is make predictions about how he will behave under various circumstances, based on the observations you have made of his behaviour so far. To ignore an observation with strong statistical power because you don't like it is simply unscientific.
> based on the observations
> you have made of his
> behaviour so far
That's what interviews and resumes are for. I would be interested to know how you would practically hire for race while not being hit by the halo effect for one race on one hand, and not missing strong candidates through racism on the other.'Popularist'. Isn't it better to spell out what is meant here rather than use a word often by elites (self selected smaller powerful groups) to refer to any democratic decision of which the elite does not approve? It's one of those rolling stone expressions that saves its users time and effort by carrying with it a boat-load of subtext.
> However let's say the figure is 50%.
It's not. > Does the argument still follow?
Yes. Given two people with similar academic achievements and no history of violence, discriminating between them is ridiculous. Treating individuals different based solely on their skin colour would still have no scientific or logical basis, as you'll still have many many stupid and violent green skinners, and peaceful and intelligent blue skinners.All that the "studies" will do is discourage natural bigots from looking at the traits of an individual.
> At what % would we inevitably be forced to pay
> attention?
At the point where you could reliably extrapolate about a given individual based on their skin colour more accurately than you could based on their personal history to date. > 'Popularist'. Isn't it better to spell out what is
> meant here
You're welcome to substitute the word "facile" if you've imbued "popularist" with too much meaning.As noted in my comment, the author looks exclusively at white people. More importantly, he looks at a variety of long term (aka multi-decade) studies from a variety of US sources and analyzes that data.
But if you want to keep arguing straw men, please feel free. I won't interrupt further.
Let's say that green people have a higher rate of suicide attempts when they have mental illness X. This is very useful knowledge -- this means that one should treat X in green people more aggresively, because it's more dangerous for them.
Let's say that green people are more likely to suffer from alcoholism. This is very important for green people themselves (they might prefer being teetolaters for that reason) and for organisations that try to prevent alcoholism -- they should target green people more in order to be more effective at decreasing the number of alcoholics.
I can go on and provide such examples. Do you consider that in these cases there is still almost no practical use, that these examples are thought up and in real life you don't get such or something else?
> This is very useful
> knowledge -- this means that
> one should treat X in green
> people more aggresively,
> because it's more dangerous
> for them.
No you shouldn't, you should asses each patient individually, especially if - as per say qualification for a job - this fact is discernible by actually examining the person. Otherwise you will let a small 10% increase in likelihood for one group blind you to the needs of another.Assessment means making observations; making observations means observing; observing means actually opening your eyes to the facts as they are. You'd be killing your patients if you ignored the fact that greens commit suicide more often on average.
When you understand the reason you have a chance at actually making things better.
I.e. use the data after seeing the performance of someone, rather than using it to predict their performance.
> When you understand the reason
This right here is the problem.Armed with a small amount of data about information over a population on average gives you absolutely no information about any specific case, and the green-skinned child gets special treatment to bring them up to scratch, where the blue-skinned child gets written off as "she's achieving less well because blue-skinned children do".
That's the problem, and that's why people in "polite societies" ignore these studies.
That's akin to saying that being armed with all of medical science's knowledge about appendicitis gives one absolutely no information about any specific case. There's a valuable point buried deeply there (every case is different), but the statement itself is just plain wrong. A physician or surgeon must have reasons to treat a specific instance of appendicitis differently than the statistically expected range of instances; a person would have reasons to treat a random green or blue person differently than the statistically expected range of persons.
> the green-skinned child gets special treatment to bring them up to scratch, where the blue-skinned child gets written off as "she's achieving less well because blue-skinned children do".
Economically speaking, investing resources in bringing green children up to scratch has a higher rate of return than doing the same for blue children. That really does mean that spending resources on the latter is wasting them on average (although certainly not in specific cases, where it really is a good investment). So, do you impoverish the world by wasting resources or do you enrich it by prudently investing them?
You also seem to want to reduce something to skin-color that has been scientifically identified as more than skin color.
1) Your point is based on ignoring often repeated and consistent (over decades) science; and
2) I think your argument generalizes something (to skin color) that is very specific (I.Q.)
I will go further and say that I think you are being disingenuous about reducing the problems that affect different races to simply skin color.
2) The article this conversation is attached to is specifically genetics related.
2) Yes, but the comment you were replying to (and made) was not.
Let's say you live in a society where there are blue and green people. A study shows a genetic basis for a difference - on average across the whole population - where blue people are 10% less intelligent and 10% more violent.
What's next? Are you justified in preferring to hire green people? No. Are you justified in having greens-only policies? Of course not, that's not how averages work. Is there any basis for any kind of segregation? Any basis for any color-based policies? No.
But you can be sure that there will be green people trying to use these studies to show themselves as superior, as a basis for discrimination, for popularist politics, and all the other associated bullshit.
It's precisely because there's almost no practical use for studies like these, but they are absolutely pounced upon by racists and opportunists, that they're 'generally forbidden to be discussed in "polite" company'.