edit: adding actual explanation
I don't think I subscribe to the idea the that we need to instrument everything to collect data for eventual ML (especially if that data is going to be privately owned). I can see why that would be appealing especially if you are a large software company involved with ads.
If there really is a killer ML model for a particular IoT device then let me opt in/out and the data collecting can be anonymous, no login required. Being online should not be required for its function.
edit 2: realized I did not address the point on updates
Self updating devices I am more on the fence about. Ideally I would have some control over what is getting updated and when and the ability to revert things and schedule the updates.
It would also be great if these devices used ssl and signatures for updates. There are horror stories of them opening up tftp and using http in the clear.
If this is too hard for IoT makers get right maybe hubs are the way to go? Not sure but the fewer things phoning home via the internet on my network the better I guess.
ML algos can be pretrained before shipment and the model baked into the device. Online training can be gamed just like search optimization games Google search; in fact it is a pretty big security hole.
That way there is a single authoritative device to secure and control everything with, a single device to reset if it becomes compromised, etc. Updates can be in cryptographically signed bundles from their manufacturers. And any smart algorithms can be run through the server. Arbitrary code execution on devices would be strongly discouraged by industry practice.
Seems like an opportunity.
Maybe that will win but it if we really want something that lives up to the hype maybe we need something as game changing as http and the internet itself was in the day?
Stuff like http://mqtt.org/ and some of the open source projects like hass might help but it seems like we need something more. As the article says its not just security that is suffering but the over all UX sucks right now.
Having a million device thats that are difficult to audit, configure and sensitive to internet and service outages is a nightmare recipe.
Not sure how to solve this in an easy to fix way but it makes me miss the days of RFCs and standards. Seems like we need something higher level than z-wave, zigbee and 802.11.