Re:A Tragic Loss
by jsprogrammer on Thursday June 30, 2016 @11:01PM
(#12013625)
An engineer should know nothing by instinct.
Adding redundancy was incorrect. Redundancy should be inherent to the design. If one must be added, the design is already a failure.
Redundancy does not mean adding a new component, but maintaining operation under component failure. For example, if the engines fail, it should still be possible to make a controlled landing.
If you can build an airliner with 100% failsafe redundancies at a cost that makes you competitive with the incumbants I'll be the first to buy a ticket. Heck, I'll be the first to invest.
Re:A Tragic Loss
by jsprogrammer on Friday July 01, 2016 @01:08AM
(#12013997)
Nothing is 100% failsafe. Machines can be designed that will not enter known failure modes, given they are operating in within known conditions. If such a machine is detected to be able to enter a failure mode in expected coming conditions, it should not be used commercially.
Cf. The grounding of all Boeing 787s: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_787_Dreamliner_batter...
> If a component may fail
As has already been pointed out to you, all components may fail, including any that you add to compensate for the potential failure of other components.
An engineer should know this by instinct.