News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Tragic Loss by ModernMech on Thursday June 30, 2016 @06:32PM (#12012371)
> It makes me a bit sad that the political zeitgeist in the tech community is leaning towards "acceptable losses" when it comes to accidents in automated cars

Yes, this is another thing that makes me so angry about this situation.

Back in the day, I worked on a project to give autonomy to power wheelchair systems. In order to get it to market, we had to go through FDA approval, which involved testing the equipment in every conceivable scenario. We had to show how it performed in rain, snow, dust storms, sunlight, etc. and it had to be incredibly rigorous, defining all limitations, and how the user would be impacted if the systems failed.

If we came the FDA and said "Our system works in many scenarios, but we've found a pathological case where on certain sunny days it will crash into certain brightly colored objects, resulting in almost certain death for the user" we would have been summarily rejected. Non starter.

And yet we're willing to put a system with the above disclaimer (which should have been known to Tesla engineers. This is sensors 101.) on the market with absolutely no oversight? Seriously?

Re:A Tragic Loss by thaumasiotes on Thursday June 30, 2016 @07:39PM (#12012745)
It occurs to me that wheelchairs have a very low fatality rate when not autonomous, but the same is not true for cars.
Re:A Tragic Loss by mjevans on Friday July 01, 2016 @01:35AM (#12014069)
From the description of this accident it sounds as if the Tesla was traveling normally down a lane, and happened to cross UNDER a vehicle which was bisecting that lane (the precise conditions were not clear from my reading; it could be that the trailer was at a crossroads of somekind, or that it was veering across said lane).

In the case of any normal crossing or intersection the driver should have taken over manual control. In the case of a sudden deviation of other vehicles planned paths, I have doubts the driver could have reacted in a timely and safe manor, even without the automation. Though an even more complete sensor system may have allowed the automation to detect and react faster than a human could.

Re:A Tragic Loss by rohit89 on Thursday June 30, 2016 @07:43PM (#12012771)
Doesn't Tesla have to get approval from the NHTSA for their autopilot?
Re:A Tragic Loss by jfrisby on Thursday June 30, 2016 @08:28PM (#12013002)
Except that the car wasn't autonomous here.

The human behind the wheel had been explicitly instructed to keep hands on the wheel and feet on the pedals -- and that it was his responsibility to override the machine's judgement if circumstances warranted.

Re:A Tragic Loss by rasz_pl on Thursday June 30, 2016 @09:14PM (#12013182)
yet all the PR material talks about autonomous driving, car drives itself wink wink
Re:A Tragic Loss by jfrisby on Thursday June 30, 2016 @10:20PM (#12013480)
PR is PR -- and yes, the ultimate vision is to get to trustworthy un-assisted self-driving.

And yet, before you can engage this mode the Tesla gives you a very stern warning that it's NOT perfect, and you DO need to keep an eye on what decisions it's making and you MUST keep your hands on the wheel.

We're not talking pages of obtuse legalese, we're talking about a single screenful of clear, straightforward warning text.

Also, as a licensed driver, you have obligations that you are expected to be mindful of, not the least of which is maintaining control of your vehicle at all times.

Are some people going to ignore it? Unfortunately, that's likely. But despite that reality, Tesla's autopilot is apparently doing better in terms of accidents per 100m miles driven than unassisted drivers.