News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The link between language and cognition is a red herring by coldtea on Thursday June 30, 2016 @08:38AM (#12008062)
>Oddly enough, this particular desire must have passed me by, because I have never felt it. I am not waiting to hear what my animals have to say about themselves

Confirmation bias?

>This might be true for simple attitudes free from moralisations (‘What is your favourite music?’), but it seems almost pointless to ask people about their love life, eating habits, or treatment of others (‘Are you pleasant to work with?’). It is far too easy to invent post-hoc reasons for one’s behaviour, to be silent about one’s sexual habits, to downplay excessive eating or drinking, or to present oneself as more admirable than one really is. No one is going to admit to murderous thoughts, stinginess or being a jerk.

I'm not sure where this person lives, but they don't seem to have much social experience. People lie yes. But they also tell the truth all the bloody time too, even for what would seemingly be their most private thoughts.

Heck, sometimes you need to really try hard to stop them from endlessly filling you in into what they believe is the truth -- including about their flaws.

>In one study, female college students reported more sex partners when they were hooked up to a fake lie-detector machine, demonstrating that they had been lying when interviewed without the lie-detector.

Well, duh. An interview situation, and with a lie-detector attached to your hand to boot, where you're being asked to reveal private data to a random stranger/official, is nothing like confiding to another human being.

>There is a notable irony here. In an earlier age, the absence of language was used as an argument against the existence of thought in other species. Today I find myself upholding the position that the manifest reality of thinking by nonlinguistic creatures argues against the importance of language.

The real irony is not seeing that the "hand gestures" and other signals the author seems to appreciate, also constitute a language (as they have all the essential attributes of one -- actual verbalizations in sound or writing are secondary expressions of having a language).

There are no comments on this comment yet.