News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by docgnome on Thursday March 18, 2010 @12:29AM (#1200462)
I like how Mozilla gets all the blame for refusing to support a non-free solution, instead of Google, Apple, and Microsoft for choosing a proprietary solution.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by bcrescimanno on Thursday March 18, 2010 @12:33AM (#1200468)
I'd personally contend that MS, Apple, and Google didn't "choose proprietary," they chose 1) the current market leading format 2) ...that has the most video content available online already 3) ...that can be hardware accelarated 4) ...that offers the best quality to size ratio.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by docgnome on Thursday March 18, 2010 @12:43AM (#1200482)
You're right of course. Free vs Non-Free had nothing to do with it. I just really hate how everyone is hating on Mozilla for making a choice that is consistent with their principles.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by blasdel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @03:14AM (#1200702)
They have a custom auto-installer for Flash baked into Firefox, and they've even distributed the binaries to it from addons.mozilla.org.

Nobody that hasn't already been wanking over it is going to start using Theora. Authors will just fall back to Flash playing h.264 in mp4 containers via HTTP like they've been doing for years, which Mozilla is eager to support.

There's nothing consistent about their principles.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by dtf on Thursday March 18, 2010 @04:26AM (#1200782)
They don't have to cough up $5 million to support Flash. That's a priniciple I can understand.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by blasdel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @05:51AM (#1200878)
I wouldn't be surprised if they'd spent millions promoting Theora to the exclusion of all else (they reinvent the wheel by linking directly with liboggplay, instead of using libavcodec or the platform DS/QT/GS like everyone else)

The salaries of all the cheerleaders and wheel-reinventors have to add up to something substantial. They've got piles of Google cash — they stopped begging for donations after their $60m search-referral windfall in 2006 got publicized, but they've gotten secretive about their financials after that.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by kinetik on Thursday March 18, 2010 @06:12AM (#1200903)
Google will help you find more recent financial details. The 2008 financials are right here: http://blog.lizardwrangler.com/2009/11/19/state-of-mozilla-a...
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by blasdel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @07:51AM (#1201024)
Thanks, that's a lot clearer than it used to be.

I had found the 1099s a while back, but they stopped showing the whole picture after the Mozilla Corporation was created to take the revenue.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by barrkel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @06:14AM (#1200905)
I have little confidence in the stability of most video decoders in the face of corrupt data. The smaller the dependency set here, the better for stability.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by allyt on Thursday March 18, 2010 @04:39AM (#1200797)
Ugh. Please, read the other side of the "argument", I was going to say "research", but seriously, the information is 5 seconds of google-fu away: http://shaver.off.net/diary/2010/01/23/html5-video-and-codec...
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by blasdel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @06:05AM (#1200894)
I'd already read it when it was published along with the rest of the Mozilla employee apologia.

They don't have to bundle a h.264 decoder with the browser — Google is the only one that does that with their binaries (depending on how many transcoding machines they had for youtube, they may have already been paying the full license fee), and they're nice enough to dynamically link with libavcodec, so if you build it yourself you can just symlink to your platform's copy, and get every codec under the sun instead of just wav, mp3, aac, vorbis, h.264, and theora.

Apple and Microsoft just link with their native platform libraries (QT & DirectShow), and use the licensed codecs they already licensed to bundle so your computer can function in the real world.

Opera's using GStreamer on at least some of their platforms, but I think it's with a private copy. GStreamer would be a great fit for Mozilla if they'd get their heads out of their asses: they could even bundle their whole own private copy with only their foss-wank decoders. They don't even have to make it fall back to the platform libraries, as long as it's possible to drop in more decoders. They could even implement the same 'a proprietary plugin is missing' thing they do for Flash, and just download the binaries from the upstream developers (most of whom are based in western europe).

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 18, 2010 @07:44AM (#1201017)
IE9 is bundling the codecs (otherwise it wouldn't work on Vista). Mozilla is bundling codecs. Google Chrome is bundling codecs. Opera bundles codecs on all platforms but Linux.

Apple gets you to install Quicktime on Windows if you want video in Safari.

Any thoughts on why you'd want to support every codec under the sun (and pay licence fees for most of them) if the market externalities and network-effects lead to only one codec being used? Why argue for "choice" if you know that will lead to people being forced to support one particular codec?

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by blasdel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @08:16AM (#1201061)
IE9 could always install it as a DirectShow filter on Vista like the Media Center stuff does. Google Chrome loosely bundles ffmpeg, which you can just swap out with one that isn't denuded. I don't think you can install Safari on Windows without Quicktime.

You'd ideally support every codec under the sun by falling back to the platform's API. That "choice" would probably lead to people being forced to support one particular codec (h.264 for now), but it means that they don't have to pay for it. It also takes it out of the total control of the browser vendors — so it provides a path for Dirac/etc. to take off in the future.

There's also the ability for minority codecs to persist without gross transcoding (you can always fall back to a download link + VLC, which is what you had before). One of the worst things about the Theora debacle is that nearly all of the video out there is extra-lossily transcoded from more efficient files.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by barrkel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @06:15AM (#1200906)
IE dragging in random codecs is one of the reasons I don't use it. As it is in Firefox, I have realplayer and quicktime plugins disabled.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by mfukar on Thursday March 18, 2010 @09:24AM (#1201191)
Consistency would only matter if Mozilla offered a better alternative, that had the potential to become a popular lead standard. They don't, so the only way for them out of this in my humble and limited point of view is to join Netscape in oblivion.

Of course, since I'm so humble, you can ignore me.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by jmillikin on Thursday March 18, 2010 @01:09AM (#1200538)
I don't think it's fair to blame Google here -- after all, Chrome supports Theora and Vorbis natively. If they want to pay for licenses, that's their decision.

The problem is when a browser doesn't support Theora/Vorbis at all, such as Safari or current news regarding IE9. I'm personally hoping that the released version of IE9 will support Theora/Vorbis -- very unlikely, but a man can dream.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by docgnome on Thursday March 18, 2010 @03:20PM (#1202235)
Right, I think my original comment was worded badly. I'm not trying to say that Google deserves blame for the choice they made. It's not what I would have chosen but they can chose anything they want. I don't like that a lot of people seem to be mad at Mozilla for not being willing to support H.26whateverhtheeheckitis.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by reconbot on Thursday March 18, 2010 @01:14AM (#1200544)
I'm really confused why chrome (and now IE9) doesn't support Theora/Vorbis when it's FREE and USEFUL for them to do so. I think I'm missing something.

I do know if you build your own Chromium you can use a non neutered library of ffmpeg and play every codec it supports instead of just mp4.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by jmillikin on Thursday March 18, 2010 @01:22AM (#1200560)
(I think the "chrome" in your post is a typo, do you mean Safari?)

Apple doesn't support Theora in Safari because the iPhone doesn't have a Theora hardware decoder. They bluster a bit about submarine patents, but really, their refusal boils down to the iPhone. If desktop Safari supports Theora and the iPhone doesn't, users will complain. If playing some videos on the iPhone uses the battery faster than advertised, users will complain.

Microsoft, of course, has a long-lasting and well-documented dislike towards open formats. Whether IE9 supports Theora and Vorbis will depend on internal company politics -- "Free Is Bad" vs. "Lets Not Fuck Up IE Again".

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by buster on Thursday March 18, 2010 @01:56AM (#1200608)
It's funny how one can see that you are a mac/iPhone user.. You are, aren't you? ;)

No, Apple stated that they don't support Theora "claiming that the lack of known patents on Theora doesn't rule out the threat of submarine patents that could eventually be used against adopters." http://arstechnica.com/open-source/news/2009/07/decoding-the...

They also said that they have no hardwaredecoder, but this is just an excuse, imo. Video decoding is done by DSPs and DSP are designed to be programmable quite flexible. Apple/Whoever just would have to do that.

All in all, the whole situation is very clear when you look at it with the "patent view" ;)

MS: -has Windows Media Player, WMV, pays MPEG Patent fees anyway -> H.264

Apple: -has Quicktime, pays MPEG Patent fees anyway -> H.264

Mozilla: -no license -> Theora

Opera: -no license -> Theora

Goole: -no Codecs but youtube is in mpeg, but can easily switch to theora -> H.264+theora

MS and Apple have reasons to use the H.264 format: they already pay those fees, have expertise with the format, can "supress" the competition with it. Because MS could build in theora support, but what Mozila can't is to build in h.264 format (without paying). Mozilla can only lose this battle and MS&Apple are quite happy about it. There goes the competition. Typical stupid, "selfish", proprieatry bullshit-decission.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by KirinDave on Thursday March 18, 2010 @12:12PM (#1201646)
What this all dances around is that, from a technical standpoint, the H.264 codec delivers superior results in nearly every situation that Apple, Microsoft, and Google want to use video.

So why should they use Theora? Are we really making ideological arguments for technology decisions now? The way to stop patents from ossifying the tech industry is to stop filing patents. To do this, people like us are going to have to start pushing back in our companies and displaying prior art whenever the subject of patents comes up with corporate lawyers.

Meanwhile, Mozilla is a corporation. They're a big kid making sums with an "m" at the end. They're one of the majority shares of the browser market last time I looked. They're going to have to start to play the game like a real company and stop expecting everyone to softball them. Already they're behind on the technology front; I only see Chrome and Safari on every hacker's screen that _I_ see these days. If they keep expecting the industry they've so eagerly entered to coddle them, then their future prospects are dim at best.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by carussell on Thursday March 18, 2010 @09:53PM (#1203107)
"They're one of the majority shares of the browser market last time I looked." (Emphasis mine.)

There can be only one majority share by definition.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by KirinDave on Friday March 19, 2010 @01:54AM (#1203481)
Cool story, bro.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by blasdel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @03:26AM (#1200710)
It's not 'just an excuse' — the fosstards+Nokia only started working on a DSP decoder in the last year, and haven't shipped anything yet.

Before that there were ZERO independent efforts at implementing Theora decoders — there was the original On2 code dump, and a transliteration of that to Java called Cortado (used in an applet player by Wikimedia). There are no independent encoders, just the original code dump and a deshittifying refactoring (v1.1, Thusnelda) that was just released a few months ago.

Before it was tied as an anchor around the necks of the FOSS partisans, Theora was a really awful totally proprietary (in the original sense) codec. It was open sourced because it was never once licensed to a customer, and On2 only pushed one codec at a time (they never improved them, just forked off a new one).

As for the patents, MS has been shipping h.264 decoders with their OSes for a while now (they always left MPEG2 decoding the OEMs to bundle until recently too). Apple actually has patents in the h.264 licensing pool!

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by kinetik on Thursday March 18, 2010 @05:58AM (#1200886)
The DSP decoder was implemented by David Schleef and funded by Mozilla. Nokia weren't involved with it at all. It was released last year, and you can use it right now: http://www.schleef.org/blog/2009/11/11/theora-on-ti-c64x-dsp...

FFmpeg has had an independent VP3 and Theora decoder for years. The history goes back to 2003. The source is here: http://git.ffmpeg.org/?p=ffmpeg;a=blob;f=libavcodec/vp3.c

The claim about VP3 never being licensed to a customer is pretty ridiculous. Do you have a source?

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by blasdel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @08:05AM (#1201045)
The DSP code was written for Mozilla Fennec to use, and the only platform using Fennec is the Nokia N900. Has Nokia shipped the decoder yet?

I just found that libavcodec implementation today — It looks leagues better than the Xiph implementation, but none of the FOSStard projects I've seen use it — most link directly with liboggplay, or if they're transcoders use ffmpeg to decode the input to feed to libtheora.

That's just the thing: I can't find a source to the contrary. On2 never bragged about licensing VP3 to a customer, just distribution of the decoder through Apple and Real's auto-download mechanisms, and one in-house hosting/consulting deal with TheStreet.com in 2000.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by kinetik on Thursday March 18, 2010 @04:27PM (#1202403)
The DSP port is an API compatible port of libtheora. Anything that is linked against libtheora can make use of the DSP port simply by linking against it. Nokia haven't shipped a major OS release since the DSP port came out, so even if they were going to ship it and/or Fennec (I have no idea), they haven't had a chance to do so yet. It's probably worth pointing out that the DSP port is not specific to the N900 or Maemo at all. It targets the C64x+ DSP, which is part of the OMAP3 SoC. The N900, Motorola Droid, and Palm Pre all ship an OMAP3 that includes the DSP.

FFmpeg has an independent decoder but for encoding it uses libtheora. The FFmpeg decoder has traditionally been slower than libtheora and didn't implement all of the Theora spec. It implemented VP3 plus the part of the spec that the Theora 1.0 (and earlier) encoders produced, but failed to decode spec-compatible output from the Theora 1.1 encoder (which libtheora 1.0's decoder handles just fine). There has been a lot of development of the FFmpeg decoder recently, so most of these issues are fixed. It's possible that the decoder is faster than libtheora now (as of the last 2-3 months), but I haven't benchmarked it.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 18, 2010 @05:48AM (#1200874)
You've got quite a few facts wrong in this short rant.

Nokia isn't working on a Theora DSP decoder. In fact Nokia along with Apple were among the strongest voices against including Theora as an interoperable baseline codec in HTML5. (It was revealed, but only later, that Nokia are, like Apple, in the MPEG patent pool). Mozilla are writing the software needed for "hardware" decode on the n900 and similar platforms.

If a DSP decoder counts as an independent Theora decoder then there's several other things that would count too. I would have thought the ffmpeg Theora/VP3 decoder would have counted by any measure.

The On2 code was rewritten, even for Theora 1.0. Theora 1.1 was another major rewrite but mostly of the encoder (though that work also made the decoder faster).

While more an omission or curious framing than an incorrect fact it could be suggested that since Theora is BSD licenced then there is little need for anyone to rewrite it. This is unlike, for example, H.264 where there is no liberally licensed reference implementation (and some experts from x264 think that most independent implementations are atrocious since the spec is easy to mess up). So you seem to have portrayed a strength as a weakness here.

You (or someone else round here) have claimed before that VP3 was never licensed to a paying customer and this is why it was released as open source. I don't think this even makes logical sense, but moreover I believe it to be entirely untrue. Do you have a source for this surprising claim? (The official On2 line from the guy who suggested it is that they open sourced VP3 to "scorch the earth" for competitors as they moved onto the next generation codec)

On2 backported changes introduced in VP6-8 and VP6 improved measurably as a result.

Microsoft only introduced H.264 decoders in Windows 7.

Microsoft are also MPEG patent pool members.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by blasdel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @07:37AM (#1201006)
Nokia's the one that's going to ship it, and shipping speaks louder than FUD. For some reason I thought Nokia was funding it too, but maybe their contributions to Mozilla are just patches to the browser.

Thanks for pointing out the ffmpeg VP3 decoder, which appears to have SSE2 optimizations and everything — yet another reason why Mozilla should be linking with libavcodec or GStreamer :)

I remember that the original libtheora alpha release was just the On2 BSD-licensed code dump rearranged with the copyright strings changed and working makefiles, but I can't find the original On2 tarball anywhere to confirm that. I just did some spelunking into their old SVN repo, the first few commits seem to be him checkpointing as he's working his way through munging the original files. The alphas just add library glue and their parochial container format fuckedness. The library infrastructure changes a lot more towards 1.0 but it doesn't look like any of the real codec implementation changes at all. http://svn.xiph.org/trunk/theora-old/

There being nothing absolutely forcing independent rewrites just means everyone sticks with one really shitty implementation they don't understand very well, instead of there being a whole spectrum of implementations competing with one another and calling them on their shit — that's how you get implementations like x264. DarkShikari has sassed the crappy commercial h.264 implementors, but he's got vitriol for the single-implementation proprietary codecs.

I'd love to see if someone can find anyone that really used VP3 pre-Theora, because I can't. There's announcements about them making the decoder available through various channels, and then they open-source it a year after 3.2 was shipped. The only thing I can find is this press release touting On2's use of it on a dot-bomb contract: http://www.on2.com/index.php?id=486&news_id=399

VP4 and VP5 fared only a little better, getting distributed in Winamp and Realplayer and getting shelved after a year. VP6 made them huge piles of money after it was bundled in Flash. VP7 got used for Skype's video chat. VP8 appears to complete the circle, with nobody using it that I can find.

Windows 7 was released a year ago. MS is shipping IE9 for Vista, so all those users will probably get the DirectShow codec. I think if you get it if you install the Zune software (it's always been supported on the hardware), or the Media Center stuff from the last several years. The Xbox 360 has shipped it since 2007.

I knew Microsoft were MPEGLA members (they have a huge stake in the VC-1 pool, after all), but I hadn't noticed that they have a big stake in the AVC/h.264 pool as well (Apple has one patent in it).

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 18, 2010 @08:04AM (#1201042)
Nokia is almost certainly not going to ship any Theora or Vorbis support in any of their devices. This would be a substantial turnaround in their previous stance which their developer and open source relations folk have made clear is set as policy at a much higher level than they can do anything about. Maybe Meego will change this but I doubt it.

In the meantime though they have one of the few mobile systems where you can add your own system level code to support video and audio codecs of your choice so it's not all bad.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by blasdel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @08:22AM (#1201072)
Even if they keep up the FUD, they are shipping an open platform with an official Mozilla Fennec build, so Mozilla could implement the same kind of codec-downloader that they did for Flash.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by buster on Thursday March 18, 2010 @03:37AM (#1200723)
I see, h.264 support is a really bad idea. With "Apple actually has patents in the h.264 licensing pool!" you scared atleast me away. So one competitor has patents and the competition should use that too? nooo, sir.

So, dirac it shall be then?

edit: Also you mention technical reason. My reasoning still is: This is not about technical reasons it is a pure political decision to get rid of competition in a shameless way. You don't want to tell me that two of the biggest software companies in the world which did their own codecs (quicktime, wmv) arent capable of shipping a decent theora decoder in their browsers? It's just a stupid manager decision in the likes of "haha, mozilla can't/won't pay mpeg fees, we'll use that".

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by blasdel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @04:04AM (#1200743)
The patent licensing is dirt cheap, the people paying in are almost exclusively hardware makers, shipping hundreds of millions of embedded devices a year. Apple having a few patents in the pool just makes a janitorial-sized line-item in their budget even cheaper since they get payments back too. Apple has paid to license a suite of codecs for every install since the dawn of Quicktime (though they charged $20 for an MPEG2 encoder for a long time), supporting h.264 <video> costs them nothing — they already paid a nickel for your iTunes install.

Dirac is terrific, but it'll be another few years before it's ready; and it'll be much longer before the available bandwidth and demand for quality exists — it'll pick up among people pirating 1080p video, but it doesn't scale down enough for the youtubes of the world.

QuickTime is not a codec and never has been, it's a container, which happens to have been standardized as the MPEG4 container, because it doesn't suck ass like everything else (save Matroska). WMV is mostly a container too — they had a good 'proprietary' WMV codec called VC-1, but they got pwned with submarine patents after they lobbied it into the HD standards war.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by cookiecaper on Thursday March 18, 2010 @09:51PM (#1203103)
The patents are cheap now while H.264 is a candidate for adoption as the de-facto standard in HTML5 video. In a few years, once H.264 HTML5 video is ubiquitous, and no one can watch anything online without a H.264 decoder, licenses won't be so cheap.

It is pretty dangerous to allow H.264 to become widespread here. It would represent a serious barrier to entry for upstart browser vendors. This is bad.

We want to invite as much competition as possible. It's true that if you only account for Mozilla, it's not that big of a deal, because at the end of the day they can afford to pay some licensing fees if they have to. It is a big deal for something like Midori or Epiphany or Konqueror or any other such projects because their usability will be strongly diminished by an inability to play online video. This is a bad thing.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by jmillikin on Thursday March 18, 2010 @10:13AM (#1201318)
It's funny how one can see that you are a mac/iPhone user.. You are, aren't you? ;)

I don't own a smartphone; if I did, it would never ever be an iPhone. I do own a macintosh laptop, but run Linux on it.

The reason I think the submarine patent is fake is that submarine patents are a risk for H.264 as well. MPEG LA are laying low until H.264 is widespread and they can really apply the thumbscrews; who know how many dozens of other companies are using the same strategy, biding their time until payday?

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by kinetik on Thursday March 18, 2010 @01:17AM (#1200551)
Chrome (and Chromium) ship with support for Ogg Theora and Vorbis. I'm not sure where this misconception comes from.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by spatulon on Thursday March 18, 2010 @09:01AM (#1201133)
The misconception comes from Google not wanting to use Theora on Youtube.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by timthorn on Thursday March 18, 2010 @04:39AM (#1200795)
Supporting Theora is not free. There may be no licensing costs, but every feature costs developer time, testing time, increases the surface area for bugs and so on. In a hobby project there may be no financial cost - but in commercial software there certainly is.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by DrJokepu on Thursday March 18, 2010 @05:48AM (#1200872)
None the less, Chrome _does_ support Theora (and Vorbis).
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by daleharvey on Thursday March 18, 2010 @12:36AM (#1200473)
none of those change the fact that they "chose proprietary"
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by bcrescimanno on Thursday March 18, 2010 @12:38AM (#1200477)
Sure--but they chose pragmatically. Proprietary vs. open was not as major a factor as say; not forcing 9 of 10 businesses to re-encode all of their video if they want it to work with Firefox.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 18, 2010 @05:14AM (#1200830)
Yes, it's entirely pragmatic for Apple and Microsoft to choose an option that can't be implemented in Free Software or even free software produced by small companies. Anti-competitive actions are always pragmatic if you're not going to get punished for them.

I don't really blame them though. The US government allows software patents and has a terrible patent system that massively favours entrenched interests and blessed the MPEG patent pool which created the current mess. (Bear in mind that the US government spent most of the 20th century breaking up patent pools because they were anti-competitive).

People say "there's too many patents around video codecs" but no one stops to ask why. The answer is because anyone who gets a patent into MPEG gets an equal cut of the profits, doesn't matter how small, useless or even counter-productive your idea is. It all adds to the patent thicket that prevents competition.

How can anyone say with a straight face that they are choosing a bureaucratic monopoly because quality is so important to them?

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by GHFigs on Thursday March 18, 2010 @07:39AM (#1201011)
You're saying it's anti-competitive for companies to act in accordance with their own interests rather than go out of their way to support their competitors?
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 18, 2010 @08:00AM (#1201033)
Yes. Why would acting in their own interests be assumed to be pro-competitive?

The "invisible hand" that turns corporate self-interest into something socially beneficial only works when there is free competition and erecting barriers to entry (by excluding those who can't or won't pay patent fees) is by definition anti-competitive.

This is why countries like China are pushing for royalty-free standards. Even communist countries understand that open standards and competition are a benefit.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by GHFigs on Thursday March 18, 2010 @09:51AM (#1201266)
Forgive me for not understanding, but if I can ask for further clarification--

In your last post, you said: "Anti-competitive actions are always pragmatic if you're not going to get punished for them." From this, I conclude that when you say "anti-competitive", you are referring to actions that ought to be punished. Then, I asked if it was anti-competitive for companies to act in accordance with their own interests instead of aiding competitors, to which you say yes.

From this, I conclude that you are saying that acting in one's own self-interest instead of aiding competitors ought to be punished.

Where have I made a mistake?

erecting barriers to entry (by excluding those who can't or won't pay patent fees)

I don't understand. Native h.264 support is not mandatory for competition or spec compliance. h.264 patent fees, and Mozilla's inability/choice to not pay them only constrain what they implement. It does not prevent them from competing or from adhering to the spec.

For a counter-example, Mozilla was the driving force behind having Theora made a mandatory part of the spec, which would have excluded any parties who couldn't or wouldn't implement it. Would that have been anti-competitive?

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 18, 2010 @10:18AM (#1201334)
In an ideal world businesses would not behave anti-competitively and this would have great benefits for society.

In this particular real world you can't micromanage like that, and you'd end up with bad government if you even tried, but still companies are punished for the anti-competitive actions which are big or bad enough to be worth prosecuting, and are generally expected to refrain from doing so all by themselves. (Often they are encouraged to self-regulate by the threat of intrusive mandated regulation.)

I personally would prefer it if patents, standards bodies and a few other such institutions were reformed to encourage greater competition and prevent anti-competitive behaviour.

In the particular case of H.264 there are a range of problems with the current system, even before you bring web standards and browsers into the picture. Basically patents plus network effects are a bad mix and MPEG has the whole world on a patent upgrade treadmill. Ironically, standards were a previously successful tool to avoid proprietary vendor lock-in, but they have since been captured by the very organisations they were meant to regulate.

Making any royalty-free standard mandatory (e.g. Theora) is only an issue because of potential patent claims from trolls in general or MPEG-LA members specifically. This can and should be fixed in the patent system (e.g. China have announced plans to compulsorily licence patents that have claims on mandated standards, some US legal authorities suggest that it be your responsibility to notify standards bodies of patent issues or else you lose your patent rights, many EU member states don't consider MPEG "open" standards because they require royalties and so can't be used by government). Without that patent threat there is no substantive reason to not implement Theora (or any potential VP8 derived codec).

My own understanding is, even with the vagueness of the current patent system, that the groups who have refused to implement Theora have done so primarily because of influence brought to bear on them by MPEG-LA which makes any suggestion of anti-competitiveness of Theora circular since it relies on the existence of an anti-competive body which is using its power to prevent implementations of rival codecs.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by GHFigs on Thursday March 18, 2010 @02:31PM (#1202078)
I personally would prefer it if patents, standards bodies and a few other such institutions were reformed to encourage greater competition and prevent anti-competitive behaviour.

I agree. We undoubtedly disagree on what things and in what ways, but I don't think the current systems and organizations are operating at their best, either. On most aspects of the larger problems am very undecided, but I have a particular bee in my bonnet over this issue because I strongly disagree with Mozilla's handling of the situation.

standards were a previously successful tool to avoid proprietary vendor lock-in

They still are. That's why we're talking about a single (albeit broad) format called "h.264", which dozens of vendors support and not dozens of different competing locked-in formats.

but they have since been captured by the very organisations they were meant to regulate

I'm not sure what you mean by this. To my knowledge, the primary participants in the relevant standards bodies have always been the same ones cross-licensing their IP. That would seem to make sense: You can't have interoperable standards if the parties won't share what they have, and the most reliable way of getting someone to share what they have is to give them something in return.

Making any royalty-free standard mandatory (e.g. Theora) is only an issue because of potential patent claims from trolls in general or MPEG-LA members specifically.

I disagree. Making any codec mandatory means mandating risk. In a standard, this means implementors agreeing to take on that risk--but the parties involved in HTML5 have not agreed to take on the risk of any codec. Why they choose not to is irrelevant from the viewpoint of authoring a standard. There is no sense in publishing a standard that is full of stuff which isn't actually standard. Trying to alter reality by altering the spec would not work regardless of patents -- it would just make otherwise compliant parties non-compliant, to no end but smug satisfaction.

(It's worth noting here that h.264 was never mandated by the spec. The parties that implement it have done so for their own reasons, without being mandated.)

Without that patent threat there is no substantive reason to not implement Theora (or any potential VP8 derived codec).

The same is true of h.264, with the essential difference that licensing allows the risk to be managed, even without patent reform. As in, today. If we had to hold up all progress until the messy problems of international IP law had been solved, h.264 would be patent-free by the time we were finished.

And this on top of the fact that there is very little technical or economic reason to implement Theora. It's just not that useful.

the groups who have refused to implement Theora have done so primarily because of influence brought to bear on them by MPEG-LA

On what evidence do you make this claim?

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by lolcraft on Thursday March 18, 2010 @11:14AM (#1201482)
Then, I asked if it was anti-competitive for companies to act in accordance with their own interests instead of aiding competitors, to which you say yes.

No you didn't. The question you asked was, and I quote: "You're saying it's anti-competitive for companies to act in accordance with their own interests rather than go out of their way to support their competitors?" Note you used supporting, a passive role, rather than aiding, which is active. To state the obvious: your mistake was assuming that the process of synonymy strictly preserves meaning, which isn't the case.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by GHFigs on Thursday March 18, 2010 @12:33PM (#1201721)
Note you used supporting

Note that I used "go out of their way to support". The active role was clearly implied, and consistent with the context.

ZeroGravitas described Apple and Microsoft's choice (to use h.264) as an "anti-competitive action", and in contrasting that choice with an alternative, I thought it was obvious that I meant choosing (acting) differently, i.e. using Theora, in spite of it not being in their own interests. What else might I have meant?

If we were talking about a passive role of "supporting", then Apple (and possibly Microsoft) would have to be excluded, as their <video> implementation (at least on the desktop) allows for installing additional third-party codecs, such as Theora. In that sense Apple supports Theora, but clearly that is not what we're talking about.

I know of no other sense in this context that Apple or Microsoft could support Mozilla without also aiding them.

(The reason I stated this initially in terms of "going out of their way" was to distinguish this situation from situations in which self-interested competitors benefit each other directly, such as how Apple's work on WebKit benefited Google's work on Chrome (and vice versa). There was no argument made to suggest that choosing Theora would have been in the interests of Microsoft or Apple, though, so this was (I thought) redundant, hence the change.)

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by BigZaphod on Thursday March 18, 2010 @09:30AM (#1201212)
If companies didn't act in their own interests there wouldn't be competition!
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 18, 2010 @09:48AM (#1201258)
Can I suggest to you that, if they were not barred from doing so by law, any rational and profit driven business would eventually merge with all its market rivals to form a monopoly and extract monopoly rents? I think the facts of history are on my side here (see e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Antitrust_Act).

I am suggesting (in line with what I thought were the commonly accepted tenets of free market capitalism) that their self-interest be channelled, not that this motive is intrinsically bad, just that it is not intrinsically good since externalities and market failures can be exploited in the name of corporate self-interest without any compensating benefit to society.

"People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices." -- Adam Smith

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by andrewfox on Thursday March 18, 2010 @09:19AM (#1201171)
I think the idea that the article is “hating” or “blaming” Mozilla for anything is just a little bit overdoing it. To say the least. The article goes out of its way to empathise with and respect the Mozilla position.