News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A challenge, identify this HN user, I tried twice and failed by onetimetype on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:44PM (#1200147)
Stop trying to identify this user.

They did not issue a challenge to be identified--in fact they agree with the notion that privacy is dead, which seems to be what you're trying to prove with this exercise. They may have serious reasons for using a one time account.

If your name is one of the (very random) guesses in this post, please neither confirm nor deny that the user is you, since this could identify that user by elimination.

This item should not have so many points. The post is rubbish. A 275 word sample is long, but likely insufficient given the pool of candidates. The post did not explain what methods were used, what work in authorship identification influenced his approach, nor did he provide his ranked findings. The tries are actually failed guesses, rather than, say, different algorithms attempted. This item has now devolved into a guessing game, rather than a coding exercise.

Again, stop trying to identify this user.

written with a one time account

Re:A challenge, identify this HN user, I tried twice and failed by jacquesm on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @08:55PM (#1200166)
> The post did not explain what methods were used,

The post didn't but the original thread did, I tried matching the vocabulary of the samples to the corpus of HN comments.

> what work in authorship identification influenced his approach

This is not a scientific paper.

> nor did he provide his ranked findings.

I'm not giving my ranked results because I think two attempts from me is enough.

> The tries are actually failed guesses, rather than, say, different algorithms attempted.

They were the #1 and #2 outputs of my code.

> This item has now devolved into a guessing game, rather than a coding exercise.

No-one said that you had to guess, but human guesses are also powered by computation at some level, even if it would be very hard to figure out exactly what went on.

> Again, stop trying to identify this user.

If that request would be posted by 'onetimetoken', who posted three times then it would have some credibility.

If you are not him/her why does this upset you ?

The 'one time account used as a rhetorical device' says fairly clearly that it is just a gimmick, not some kind of terrible secret.

And if you are 'onetimetoken' you are increasing the sample size ;)

Re:A challenge, identify this HN user, I tried twice and failed by whimsy on Thursday March 18, 2010 @01:26AM (#1200568)
I assume this upsets the user because using a one time account indicates a desire not to be identified or associated with the posted content, and the user wants this preference to be honored.
Re:A challenge, identify this HN user, I tried twice and failed by Freebytes on Thursday March 18, 2010 @10:47AM (#1201423)
They find it amusing, and they do not mind. If you look at the comments of the user, they authorize their own identification if we can do so.
Re:A challenge, identify this HN user, I tried twice and failed by whimsy on Wednesday April 14, 2010 @03:55PM (#1265962)
Ah, by "the user" I meant the user that was upset, not the target of the ID hunt.

My apologies for being ambiguous.

Re:A challenge, identify this HN user, I tried twice and failed by jacquesm on Thursday March 18, 2010 @10:25AM (#1201366)