Re:“Should you encrypt or compress first?”
by unsatchmo on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @02:12AM
(#11999820)
No, read the dang article. You leak information about the content of the plaintext because you're changing the length. The crib doesn't matter with secure constructions.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:“Should you encrypt or compress first?”
by mSparks on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @02:24AM
(#11999840)
1 encrypted 512bit block is always more secure than 12 512bit encrypted blocks (average compression ratio). Larger size is always a bad thing.
Problem with compress is the protocol headers give you a known part at the start of every message. Which you can then very quickly test keys against rainbow tables or other statistical means.
The best solution i know for this is to compress, then xor with a stream cipher then run into a decent block cipher.
The "compress after encrypt" is a trick question. If your data doesnt get bigger after that your encryption implementation is royally broken.
But you definately don't want every "plaintext" message starting with "..gzip".