From Eric Ries: Sep 2008: http://www.startuplessonslearned.com/2008/09/lean-startup.ht... "1. Lean in the sense of low-burn..."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lean_manufacturing
http://www.startuplessonslearned.com/2009/12/what-is-lean-ab...
The fact that it is based on Toyota should be a clue that the "Lean" methodologies are not about size, but about efficiency. "Lean is centered around preserving value with less work"
There are people using "Lean" as a new buzzword for small.
That being said - Horowitz seems to be limiting his advice to 'high-tech' startups. Note the penultimate paragraph.
Not sure if the advice applies to startups in general.
Person A comes up with a term, let's call this term X.
Other people start mis-defining X as something else, let's call it Y.
Person B happened to talk about Y before person A talked about X.
Therefore, your argument goes, person A's definition of X is wrong?
Either I'm not following you, or your arguments are not following each other.
Eric Ries doesn't advise against getting big fast. He advises to get big as fast as possible, where "possible" is defined by the product-market fit that's been reached.
"Lean" does not mean cheap. "Lean" means focused on progress, which is measured in validated learning about your customers.
Conflating "lean" with "cheap" serves no one. This article is arguing against cheap start-ups, not against lean start-ups.
This video includes some discussion, from Eric Ries, of how people are misunderstanding "lean" to mean "whatever they think will get the VCs to fund them": http://vimeo.com/9964506
The whole "lean start-up" meme emerged with Eric Ries, as far as I know, so I think his definition of it is worth paying attention to.