News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI fighter pilot wins in combat simulation by tomlu on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @06:13PM (#11998017)
I'd guess there's a difference in kind that people get excited about.

The fighter jet AI technique is hard-coded to a very specific problem domain, and could only be reproduced in a different problem domain by doing it from scratch.

The technique used by AlphaGo is at least closer to the idea that we can eventually build generically trainable machines that can learn to do a variety of tasks, without having to code them from scratch every time.

Re:AI fighter pilot wins in combat simulation by YeGoblynQueenne on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @06:35PM (#11998120)
>> The fighter jet AI technique is hard-coded to a very specific problem domain

So are machine learning models, ultimately. Although the algorithms that build the models have more general application, once you train a model on a certain set of data, that model can only ever be used in the domain circumscribed by the data. They're one-trick ponies, yes?

>> we can eventually build generically trainable machines that can learn to do a variety of tasks, without having to code them from scratch every time.

We would however have to train them from scratch every time, for each separate task, and each time we'd need terabytes of data and megawatts of power.

Re:AI fighter pilot wins in combat simulation by gambler on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @01:45AM (#11999739)
You realize that this system uses machine learning? And that AlphaGo was custom-built to play Go?

AlphaGo has several handcoded training features, uses Monte-Carlo tree search, and was primed by a huge human-made dataset. It's not like it can be throws at other problems without heave re-engineering.