Re:AI fighter pilot wins in combat simulation
by linschn on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @11:11AM
(#11994367)
I see how it can sound appealing to a bureaucrat, but as a programmer, debugging the concurrent evaluation of thousands of "natural" language IF...THEN... rules until I find the questionable one where a threshold was defined too low or too high sounds like a nightmare.
Re:AI fighter pilot wins in combat simulation
by euyyn on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @02:23PM
(#11996176)
Rule-based systems have had for a long time the ability to automatically answer queries about why was such or such decision taken.
Re:AI fighter pilot wins in combat simulation
by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @02:05PM
(#11996021)
That would indeed be a nightmare, but trying to debug a machine-generated neural network is actually worse.
Re:AI fighter pilot wins in combat simulation
by bravo22 on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @11:27AM
(#11994501)
I imagine they would log all the inputs, as well as branches taken so they can later replay everything in a debugger. That would make the process much simpler.
Re:AI fighter pilot wins in combat simulation
by XorNot on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:58PM
(#11995373)
Being able to take the blackbox recordings of your combat drone which got shot down, reconstruct the scenario and permute the rules till you get a win, seems like...well, a big win.
Air combat is also one of those areas which does notionally have narrowly computable victory parameters - given hardware of capabilities X, there is a model we don't know which should generally predict the outcome.
Re:AI fighter pilot wins in combat simulation
by reitanqild on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @01:21PM
(#11995592)
Only if you do it wrong?
If it ends up like thousands upon thousands of if statements then you got it wrong (or so I think).
Getting it right IMO means realizing that rules are not necessarily source code but often data to be iterated over, filtered etc.
This is a form of metaprogramming that can be practiced even in Java ;-)
It is very hard to ask for management to trust a system they know nothing about, where they have literally no control over final behaviour, even if in the end it will perform better overall. In a rule-based system, instead, it is always possible to make adjustments and blame mistakes very efficiently to specific causes.
I guess this is the main reason why "true" AI is currently being used mostly in information fields, rather than on physical machines and engineering. No-one would know how to deal with the outcome of a fuzzy learned algorithm making the wrong decision. This is also a reason why autonomous cars are very interesting to me, even though I bet they are still full of ad-hoc rules in order to have a layer of "manageability" over the overall system.