News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bluetooth 5 will quadruple the range, double the speed by Gibbon1 on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @03:53AM (#11992166)
Fifteen years ago, looking at the Bluetooth spec my impression was the best way to implement it would have been to send the designers to the Siberia and then start over.

The two issues I saw were Bluetooth is based on a frequency hopping radio using a dated low performance modulation scheme. The only nice thing you could say is potentially you can build really low power radio's using that design. However that brings up the second issues, a very complicated kitchen sink base band which requires a complex software stack and power hungry processor to support it. There goes your low power, out the window. (I think there were about 20 companies trying to design low power Bluetooth transceivers circa 2000-2003, most of them never could get the power low enough or a working stack)

Hardware design issues aside, frequency hoppers have insurmountable quality of service issues for most applications. Professionally I don't think this is fixable.

They would have been better off doing the following three things.

1. Define a low speed point to point oriented modulation scheme that can be supported by 802.11 radio front ends. Probably could have implemented this as a sub-band of some sort.

2. A direct sequence spread spectrum physical layer for USB. Advantage of that is the USB stack mostly works as USB had a 10 year head start and more resources than the Bluetooth alliance ever had, or will have. If one thinks a stack like USB is 'easy' consider Microsoft had to redesign theirs three or four times.

3. Dedicated DSSS wireless headphone spec. Seriously this was the original design goal and was totally achievable until the committee responsible for the spec lost their minds.

Re:Bluetooth 5 will quadruple the range, double the speed by kabdib on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @07:10AM (#11992760)
The USB emulation thing is interesting. Unfortunately, most USB implementations are disasters, too.

Don't get me started on security. BT is probably a festering pit of remote exploits and vendor backdoors.