News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Could the Scottish Parliament Stop the UK from Leaving th... by YeGoblynQueenne on Monday June 27, 2016 @03:58PM (#11988992)
>> [EU citizens] have lived here more than long enough to become citizens and not chosen to do so.

Woa. Hang on a minute. Why do I have to become a UK citizen in order to be able to partake in the decisions that directly affect my life?

I've lived here for over a decade now. I studied here, I work here, I pay taxes, I pay contributions to the NHS. Why does it make any difference whether I'm a UK citizen or not?

In fact, the only difference between myself with British citizenship and myself without, is ... whether I have the British citizenship or not.

And yet that difference determines whether I can vote or not. How does that make any sense? It's exactly as reasonable as granting the right to vote to only men, or only Christians, or something completely unacceptable like that.

I live in this country that wants to call itself democratic. Like, it just made a point of how it loves democracy so much it's willing to jump off a cliff singing God Save the Queen because it didn't think it had enough democracy.

So how is it all so democratic that a few million active, productive people living here don't get to have a say in their own affairs?

Re:Could the Scottish Parliament Stop the UK from Leaving th... by Veratyr on Monday June 27, 2016 @05:04PM (#11989468)
Disclaimer: I'm not a British citizen, just an expat of another country.

The difference between a citizen and a resident is that a citizen has made a long term commitment to the country. A citizen has decided that they want to be a part of the country, with all of the privileges and responsibilities that entails.

Take a spectrum of immigration statii:

- Temporary resident working on a visa or similar.

- Long term resident working with indefinite leave to stay or permanent residence.

- Citizen

Now imagine what would happen if they can vote:

- Temporary resident: Doesn't necessarily care about long term effects of their vote on the country. Could vote for short term changes that benefit them then leave. Isn't integrated with the culture and could cause discontent.

- Long term resident: Hasn't committed to a long term relationship with the country so is essentially the same as a temporary resident. Has the option to become a citizen __and has chosen not to__.

Why shouldn't you agree to commit to the country long term if you want the privilege of affecting it long term?

Re:Could the Scottish Parliament Stop the UK from Leaving th... by throwaway049 on Monday June 27, 2016 @05:00PM (#11989442)
I can't recall ever hearing of a campaign for residents, as distinct from citizens, to have the vote in parliamentary elections. You were and still are free to become a citizen or even decline to become one and campaign for voting rights for permanent residents. Political change doesn't normally come from just asking nicely. It took a fight to win the vote for working class men and another fight, not just a war of words but physical violence, to get the franchise extended to women. I'm not saying you should start stockpiling weapons but you could at least do some campaigning.