Re:Digitising public domain images creates a new copyright, ...
by nitrogen on Monday June 27, 2016 @01:31AM
(#11984348)
It really is clear when it comes to faithful reproductions of public domain 2D works in the US. US copyright law doesn't regard "sweat of the brow" as sufficient justification for a copyright.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweat_of_the_brow#US_copyright...
Pedantic aside: Musk didn't exactly start Tesla...
Re:Digitising public domain images creates a new copyright, ...
by vonklaus on Monday June 27, 2016 @11:00AM
(#11986566)
I will cede you may be correct, of course the world is much bigger than America, and presumably different states and courts have different variations for coywrite, logo, ect.
You are correct Musk didn't start Tesla. However, he did create it and Eberhard basically sank the company. Also, I meant to put the Model s instead of Tesla. I will also, correct myself to say that certainly Musk himself didn't create the model s, Tesla, ect alone. The point was that patents, trademakrs and copywrite are there to protect the people who build and create things, however the system is obviously very broken.
In your example, literally writing down the words spoken during a film would be to transcribe it. If I, or another, took the time to do such a thing, it would be identical presuming we both did this correctly. This would not be creative as we are simply doing something as procedural as doing weights and measures.
I find these things somewhat arbitrary, because, conversely if I were to read aloud a book and make an audio recording, presumably that would be copywritable. If I had the rights to make such a recording, or if the work was in the public domain, I believe my voice & intonation would constitute either creativity/originality and the uniqueness would allow me to apply.
I am not a lawyer, nor am I sure whether there is precendent. The point is, that these are very similar things and it is treated very ambiguously. Should I own my own voice? Should I be allowed to simply read something and consider it a creative work? Does intonation and enthusiasm matter in the delivery of the work?
It is all a bit rediculous, and frankly copywrite should be limited substantially. However, it is clearly a case by case basis and thus super difficult.
Certainly, we would want to promote people like Elon Musk to create things like the Tesla (ironically much of it is open sourced) but at the same time, would want people to build on innovations and enjoy these things unhindered, or what is the point.