News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Digitising public domain images creates a new copyright, ... by toomuchtodo on Sunday June 26, 2016 @07:15PM (#11983282)
Does this mean if I create a 3D model of a physical object, I know hold the copyright to that objects digital representation? And if so, does anything prevent me from registering said copyright and providing it to the public domain?
Re:Digitising public domain images creates a new copyright, ... by detaro on Sunday June 26, 2016 @07:32PM (#11983352)
"Registering a copyright" doesn't exist in German law (and if I remember correctly, it only makes enforcement easier in the US, but isn't necessary).

Once you create something above the "threshold of originality", you own the copyrights to it and can freely license it if you want to (if it is a derivative of a protected work, the owner of the rights on the original gets rights as well and could potentially stop you from doing so, but in a case of a public domain work that doesn't matter). If just creating a 3D model of something is above this threshold depends on the details, generally an as-precise-as-possible replica doesn't require originality though, so probably not.

For photographs there a exists a category where this threshold doesn't apply as strongly, and the court argued that in this category, the amount of expertise and work necessary to create it was enough to make it a work of it's own. This potentially conflicts with older decisions, that did not grant pure reproductions copyright protection.

EDIT2: after reviewing the old case I had in mind: It denied protection to a copy of a photo of an original, explicitly citing that it is not desired to allow infinite copyright extension by creating copies. We'll see in the next round if removing one layer of indirection changes the situation.

EDIT: I use "freely license" above because the concept of releasing something in the public domain doesn't exist in Germany. In practice, licensing it as e.g. CC0 is the clean way of achieving the same.

Re:Digitising public domain images creates a new copyright, ... by Natsu on Sunday June 26, 2016 @11:38PM (#11984087)
Copyright is automatic in the US, but there is a form to register a copyright with the Library of Congress and registration is a prerequisite before suing for statutory (as opposed to actual) damages for infringement. A "timely" registration has a presumption of validity, but you can register at any time, including just before filing a lawsuit. This, for obvious reasons, won't enjoy as many presumptions as one registered soon after the work was made.
Re:Digitising public domain images creates a new copyright, ... by ghij on Sunday June 26, 2016 @07:46PM (#11983408)
You can't _register_ copyright. You automatically receive it with the creation of a new original work.

You can't provide it to the public domain. You can, if you have copyright on the work, publish it under a license which permits others the freedom to re-use it. The work is still copyright protected though.

The existence of copyrights on these photographs was the subject of the trial: Can these photographs be considered new (derivative) works? If so the author of the photos ―the museum― owns the copyright. If not the photos are protected by the same copyright as the paintings, although the paintings fell into the public domain as the original author has died more than 70 years ago.

If you make a 3d-model of an object which is still protected under copyright it's for a judge to decide whether you've infringed on that copyright or created a derivative work.

That's all, of course, completely separate from trademarks.

Re:Digitising public domain images creates a new copyright, ... by Bromskloss on Sunday June 26, 2016 @07:20PM (#11983302)
Registering a copyright? Is that something you can do in Germany? I thought that was something that existed only in the United States, and only a long time ago.
Re:Digitising public domain images creates a new copyright, ... by toomuchtodo on Sunday June 26, 2016 @07:28PM (#11983337)
Forgive me, in the US copyright exists immediately when a work is created (I'm unfamiliar with German law, I'm a US citizen residing in the US). You can still register your copyright to make it known with the US Copyright Office: http://www.copyright.gov/fls/sl35.pdf
Re:Digitising public domain images creates a new copyright, ... by vidarh on Sunday June 26, 2016 @11:03PM (#11983975)
It still exists in the US. Copyright is automatic in the US as just about everywhere else, but registration is necessary if you wish to seek statutory damages rather than just actual damages in the case of infringement.
Re:Digitising public domain images creates a new copyright, ... by allendoerfer on Sunday June 26, 2016 @07:28PM (#11983335)
You cannot. The German Urheberrecht is something a creator automatically is entitled to and which cannot be taken away from him.