News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by dkokelley on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @01:00PM (#119828)
"Into their coffee shops and houses, the children were building their assumptions about ownership and the social power it conveys — assumptions that mirrored those of a class-based, capitalist society — a society that we teachers believe to be unjust and oppressive."

God help those children.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by Xichekolas on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @02:16PM (#119901)
The fundamental problem with their Lego trading game (and the original Legotown) is that they assume capitalism involves a fixed amount of resources that can only be traded. In reality, the resources are constantly growing. If it was really a fixed-resource system, it would always end like Monopoly, with one person owning everything, or owning enough to always be in power at the least.

All it takes is a second to stop and realize that wealth is created, not taken. If it was all really taken, then where in the heck did we take it from? (I mean we as in the whole world.) The world is immensely more wealthy than it was a thousand years ago, and all that wealth was created by the hard work of all those generations. Surely all the wealth creation done by startups is evidence of that.

I think this is generally an economic misunderstanding that a lot of people have. To them, it's "Every dollar Bill Gates has is a dollar less for everyone else, so that is unfair." In fact, PG made this argument much better than I can, here: http://www.paulgraham.com/wealth.html

That said, I did really enjoy how these teachers approached the art of teaching children. Challenging the children to examine and modify their own worldviews seems infinitely more effective than preaching to them about 'the right way.'

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by brlittle on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @10:12PM (#120192)
"The fundamental problem with their Lego trading game (and the original Legotown) is that they assume capitalism involves a fixed amount of resources that can only be traded. In reality, the resources are constantly growing. If it was really a fixed-resource system, it would always end like Monopoly, with one person owning everything, or owning enough to always be in power at the least."

I'm confused. Are you arguing that resources in the "real world" are not finite? So we'll never run out of indium, oil, fresh water, fertile soil, etc? Because if you are, that's a fascinating viewpoint, and almost completely at odds with reality.

"Surely all the wealth creation done by startups is evidence of that."

Maybe, maybe not. A lot of the "wealth" created by startups exists nowhere but on paper.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by Xichekolas on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @10:38PM (#120208)
Yeah, looking back now I wish I had written the first paragraph with the word "wealth" instead of "resources." (Alas, the edit link has disappeared on me.) So please, when you see the word resources in my post, mentally substitute for me.

As for you second point, don't confuse money with wealth. Most startups have liquidation value (dollar value) only on paper, because there is no one to buy them, but the product they create represents wealth to someone, even if it's only one customer. If the startup doesn't create enough wealth for enough people, it will probably die, in which case it won't be creating new wealth anymore, but their product made someone's life better, even if only for a short time.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by imgabe on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @10:22PM (#120198)
Not only that but the Lego trading game completely warped the real dynamics of capitalism by assigning arbitrary external values to the different Legos. In reality, different things are worth different amounts to different people, and that's why it's worthwhile to trade them. At best they're teaching these kids to easily believe strawman arguments.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by Prrometheus on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @10:17PM (#120195)
The ultimate resource is the creative human mind:

http://cafehayek.typepad.com/hayek/2008/02/a-tribute-to-ju.h...

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by bouncingsoul on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @02:31PM (#119912)
Ha, we wrote almost the exact same thing.

And I'm in Kansas City too... Weird.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by bocajuniors on Thursday February 21, 2008 @08:32AM (#120405)
natural resources are used in the process of creating wealth.they are not unlimited. america uses a lot more natural resources than it's entitled to(europe as well). and:if you make 200 k a year in a country where avg income is 500 k i'd say that your a lot worse off than if you make 100 k in a country where the average is 100 k
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by Xichekolas on Thursday February 21, 2008 @10:20AM (#120456)
Yeah brlittle brought up my misuse of the word 'resources' in a sibling post to yours. My brain really meant to use the word 'wealth' instead. I wish I had noticed it while I still had the edit link handy, as it is quite a distracting gaffe.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by bocajuniors on Thursday February 21, 2008 @09:54AM (#120443)
some individuals are wealthy enough to pursue war. i really do think this is a very serious problem with unlimited capitalism. examples:al quaida,blackwater
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by Afton on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @01:37PM (#119863)
Does this mean you disagree? You believe that a class based capitalist society isn't unjust? Really? You think you have the same rights as anyone else in your society? Interesting.

You might think that a class-based capitalist society is the best option available, but that's a far cry from claiming that it is just and non-oppressive. The simple fact is that the statistically most likely way to be a rich person is to be born into a rich family. No one is saying that it's the only way, but if you want to lay odds its the way to bet. That's just? It plays havoc with the idea of a meritocracy.

The lesson that I understood that the kids were learning is that what you happen to have started out with doesn't give you inalienable rights. In other words, be sensitive to the fact that you got where you are _at least partially_ by luck. The rest is just figuring out what it means to be sensitive in this way.

There is another important lesson that I think the teachers missed (about how to handle the disenfranchisement that the Lego-less kids felt), but that's another story.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by goofygrin on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @01:46PM (#119870)
I certainly disagree.

Just because you weren't born into money doesn't mean you can't get there. That's the beauty of the free market, you have the OPPORTUNITY to succeed and get ahead.

If everyone and everything is the same, then why even bother doing anything better or trying?

Socialism scares me to no end because it is way easier to scream for support and get it than it is to actually make something out of yourself.

I don't know about you, but I certainly don't want to have to live in a world that is built for the LCD.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by Afton on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @02:16PM (#119900)
Actually, I agree with you. I assume that you are reading into my comment some enormous weight of dialog that I wasn't a part of. I'm unsure about how to respond since I feel like we're talking at cross purposes. So with the fair warning that we may simply continue to misunderstand each other, here goes:

Of course you can 'get there'. But that doesn't make it 'fair'. If someone has to work for 0 hours for 100% chance of success and I have to work for 2000 hours for 0.01%, that isn't just. Horatio Alger stories are, frankly, rare and far between.

The basic problem is that the outlook that a person should take on life is that they are the master of their own destiny and that they can make it on the strength of their own power. When I say "should" I just mean, that is the viewpoint of the world that makes them have the best chance of achieving success. It's a psychological trick that gives people courage, and helps them to recognize opportunities. That's a very short form of what I meant when I said that there was another lesson that the teachers missed out on.

What is frustrating to me is that people take an outlook ("I am the master of my own destiny") and apply it to the world as though it were _true_. So it is common to hear people look down on the poor by saying variants of "if only they weren't so lazy they could make something of themselves". This ignores the fact that different people have different oportunities and that those oportunities are not of their own making.

In any case, have a good day.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by mynameishere on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @02:56PM (#119931)
Snore. I count 29 instances of the word "inheritance" on this page. [1]

http://www.usatoday.com/money/2005-09-22-forbes-list_x.htm

Whenever someone wants to attack capitalism, they always seem to attack people born into wealthy families. That has nothing to do with capitalism. Nothing whatsoever.

In fact, one of the GREATEST CHANGES to take place with the industrial revolution was the reduction in the prevailance of nepotism due to the importance of technical and managerial skills, rather than clannishness. Clannishness, family preferences, primogeniture, cousin marriages, etc, are all necessary to maintain feudalism, not capitalism.

If you really hate capitalism, go straight to the real alternative: Command economy. This is where some brain dead bureaucrat decides who gets wealth based upon adherance to political orthodoxy--which is essentially what the teachers did in the end. Works great with fixed resources like toys. Doesn't work so great when the fields need tilling.

[1] EDIT: Should be several higher. They only wrote "WalMart inheritence" once.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by anewaccountname on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @10:01PM (#120185)
If 29/384 got that way purely on inheritance, then inheritance is statistically extremely significant in getting into that 384; the rich don't make up anywhere near 7.5% of the population, but that list is at a minimum 7.5% born rich. Also, as one example, Gates was born filthy rich, I don't the word "inheritance" occurs everywhere on that list where it plays a part.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by dkokelley on Thursday February 21, 2008 @11:30AM (#120504)
That list is irrelevant. The people there are not representative of the entire population. They only represent the top .xx1% and are a very poor sample.

What about the people who aren't on the list? There are a lot more of them, and they're still multimillionaires. We have no information about them, nor do we have any information from which we can derive conclusions from.

As far as the top billionaires, it is true that many of them were extremely fortunate in life and had some money from birth. Only around 30 of them made their billions that way, the others worked to turn their millions into billions, which still takes a great deal of work (and pure luck).

I see this argument going nowhere unless we can agree that everyone who has under $X to start and creates $Y over the course of their lives counts as someone who became successful through capitalism. But I doubt we can agree what the X and Y values should be.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by wallflower on Thursday February 21, 2008 @11:37AM (#120509)
For those of you who are looking to be wealthy, aim to become an accredited investor by IRS standards.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accredited_investor

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by brlittle on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @10:17PM (#120196)
"Just because you weren't born into money doesn't mean you can't get there. That's the beauty of the free market, you have the OPPORTUNITY to succeed and get ahead."

This isn't always, or even usually, true. Millions upon millions are born into this world with _no_ prospects, and _no_ opportunity, and _no_ amount of hard work, inspiration or pure luck will change that. It may be more true in America than elsewhere, but it's certainly not the rule.

And the "free market" is a recipe for monopoly and domination as much as for opportunity. The goal of the players in a free market is the elimination of opportunity for anyone but themselves. The free market does not reward altruism, so there's no incentive not to crush anyone in your way, other than personal decency. Which also doesn't pay. The market we enjoy here is anything but free, for which I'm thankful.

"If everyone and everything is the same, then why even bother doing anything better or trying?"

That's a strawman.

"Socialism scares me to no end because it is way easier to scream for support and get it than it is to actually make something out of yourself."

Out of curiosity, what's your actual experience of socialism?

"I don't know about you, but I certainly don't want to have to live in a world that is built for the LCD."

So raise the lowest common denominator. There are multiple paths to that goal, after all.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by goofygrin on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @10:48PM (#120214)
I'm short on time, but I've lived in various south american countries that are all flirting with socialism. In most cases it has been met with open arms by the poor and screams from the rich. In the end, the poor are barely better off and the rich simply buy around what the socialized stuff gives them. Price controls and other economic "flattening" certainly have poor effects on the country as well.

Certainly I feel for those in underdeveloped or regressive countries and I'm VERY thankful that I am where I am and am able to live as comfortable a life as I am living. But what am I going to do? Frankly there is very little that I can do for people in N. Korea or Zimbabwe. Socialism is not the answer for the problems in the middle east, africa or N. Korea.

And (this is getting longer than I have time for), but how do I raise the LCD? It seems to me that every day the LCD goes down further. I had a conversation today with a buddy about trying to monetize an idea and he said we needed to find a way to make it more lowbrow since stuff like that pays (see hotornot.com in its "close to porn" heyday).

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by corentin on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @02:08PM (#119892)
I'm claiming that whatever I build with natural resources I find is mine. You happen to disagree with that statement. Fine. Now, tell me how you would practice what you preach (socialism, wealth redistribution, etc.) without attacking me (or using the threat of violence, which is practically the same thing) to steal my work (or part of it).
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by davidw on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @02:14PM (#119899)
Maybe they should just let the kids play with the damn legos and enjoy themselves and not try and get all philosophical about it, one way or the other.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by corentin on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @02:22PM (#119906)
Yeah; that's what free-market anarchy is all about in the first place :)
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by euccastro on Thursday February 21, 2008 @02:39PM (#120642)
> I'm claiming that whatever I build with natural resources I find is mine.

That doesn't scale. Humanity's ability to find natural resources dwarfs the amount of natural resources to be found on earth. It's not hard to 'find' arable land, for example. Any counterclaims would have to be defended in base of some agreeable concept of justice, or failing that, via violence, actual or anticipated. Violence over resources can happen, and happens, irrespective of ideological differences.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by bct on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @05:22PM (#120040)
How do you prevent people from using the things you claim ownership to without violence?
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by corentin on Thursday February 21, 2008 @01:58AM (#120292)
I don't; so don't steal my lunch :)
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by euccastro on Thursday February 21, 2008 @02:59PM (#120662)
That's (pre) feudal rather than capitalist, and it's not actually how it's working for you. Much of your wealth is in places where you don't have the physical means to reclaim it or defend it by yourself.

Much of your money is held in custody in some bank, where you put it because you trust they'll give it back to you when you ask for it, not because you think you can strongarm the clerks into returning it to you.

Maybe your car is parked out on the street. Even if you have it in a garage of your own, if some burglars came you may find it more reasonable to let your insurance company or the police take care of it rather than risk your life trying to stop it yourself via violence.

Those mechanisms work because there are rules in place about what is reasonable use of resources and wealth, and those rules could not be stable or widely respected if you couldn't defend they're just in some way.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by anewaccountname on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @10:02PM (#120186)
"with natural resources I find"

Like all the land we took from the Indians?

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by bocajuniors on Thursday February 21, 2008 @04:29PM (#120728)
it's only yours if society accepts it as yours
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by imsteve on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @03:08PM (#119948)
What's your problem with property ownership? You want to make it so that if people actually work hard then everything gets taken from them anyway?

You're not talking about evening the score, you're talking about inhibiting people from ever getting ahead again.

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by noonespecial on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @06:10PM (#120077)
Justice and fairness are very different things. Capitalism is just, it is not fair, especially to the lazy and the willfully ignorant.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by imsteve on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @01:53PM (#119879)
Oh I see, jealousy will solve all economic problems.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by snorkel on Thursday February 21, 2008 @10:52AM (#120481)
Comrades,

The Lego bricks belong to the People! You are a friend of the Lego Revolution, are you not? I suspect you do not like our Cherished Leaders! Western ideas have poisoned you! Do not sit with us during the Snack Time Celebration! Our Great Teachers are watching you!

Also the clear Lego bricks are being collected by the People's Ministry of Security. Only Authorized Friends of the Revolution are allowed to use the clear Legos. To become an Authorized Friend you must donate cookies the People's Party Headquarters next to book shelf. DO NOT donate cookies to Headquarters of the People's Party, they are traitors, spies, and enemies of the Revolution! They must not be allowed to go play during Recess! This is the New Fairness.

Hail to our Great Teachers for teaching us the New Fairness!

- Comrade Jimmy

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by xirium on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @01:31PM (#119854)
I certainly didn't make coffee shops with Lego. However, it is political correctness to ban it. Lego is a very flexible toy which develops spatial skills and co-ordination. You can do whatever you like with Lego but these teachers don't like it because inequality can be projected onto it. I'd like to know what replacement is deemed more suitable.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by Afton on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @01:45PM (#119867)
I think you may have gotten bored and stopped reading. They got the lego back.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by wallflower on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @02:28PM (#119910)
"Brown eyed people are dumb"

Good they didn't try Jane Elliot's famous and controversial "Brown eye/Blue eye" exercise in that classroom:

http://www.janeelliott.com/

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by wallflower on Wednesday February 20, 2008 @11:08PM (#120221)
I had no idea an early childhood classroom could evolve into a Lord of the Flies scenario.

When we played our favorite game - peg ball in elementary school, we didn't think so deep. It was throw the ball against the wall and if you fumbled it/didn't catch it, run to the wall before you got pegged. I think these teachers are really imposing a Brave New World kind of lens on their microcosm of a world. Maybe it's just me I wasn't that self-aware, clued-in at their single-digit age (maybe not even now).

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by bocajuniors on Thursday February 21, 2008 @07:04AM (#120368)
i think it is quite clear that a purely capitalist society is unjust and oppressive.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by thaumaturgy on Thursday February 21, 2008 @07:40AM (#120381)
There has already been some good conversation in this thread over that, which I think at the least means that it isn't quite clear at all.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by bocajuniors on Thursday February 21, 2008 @08:39AM (#120407)
i think it's very obvious that a purely capitalistic system produces a lot of very poor people.that is it is a bad system.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by corentin on Thursday February 21, 2008 @09:00AM (#120414)
You end up with a lot of people who are relatively poor but practically rich, whereas socialism promotes a system in which nobody is richer (or poorer) than his neighbor but with the nasty side effect that everyone is practically poor.

Hence it's a relatively good system :)

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by ced on Thursday February 21, 2008 @02:57PM (#120658)
... assuming that being "practically rich" causes happiness.

There was some study a while ago that said that most people would rather have 1000$ in a society where others have 10$ than have 1 million in a society where everyone is a billionnaire. (I made up the numbers, I didn't look for the actual thing. I'm not sure how they accounted for the "inflation" that such a mythical society would have)

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by dkokelley on Thursday February 21, 2008 @07:48PM (#120911)
The thing with the study about having $1,000 but the most and having $1,000,000 but the least is that it doesn't account for what that money can get you. If everyone in the world had a billion dollars then a billion dollars would be relatively worthless.

The study should have been phrased: "If you could have only $1,000 worth of stuff but it was 100 times more stuff than everyone else, or $1,000,000 worth of stuff but it was 1000 times less than everyone else, which would you choose?"

I think the majority of people would choose to have $1,000,000 worth of stuff, even if it's the least, which translates to "I would rather be considered 'poor' in a thriving society than be considered 'rich' in an impoverished society."

Re:Why a School Banned Legos by ced on Friday February 22, 2008 @05:04AM (#121185)
That's what I meant when I said "accounted for inflation". I'll hunt up the study some day. I'm not so sure about you conclusion, though, but maybe my experience with people was different. I'm also skeptical that most people would reason that prices would go up in the billion dollar society. I think the biggest fear is: I am at the deep bottom of the social ladder.
Re:Why a School Banned Legos by bocajuniors on Thursday February 21, 2008 @09:48AM (#120434)
i didn't say that a purely socialistic society is any better.and, as long as you make more than 100k/year(which is enough to fullfill your physical needs), it really is your relative income that counts.